Football Genius wrote:Six wrote:Football Genius wrote:Six wrote:Football Genius wrote:Insua has been poor, Kelly... absolutely fantastic full european debut.
Surely Babel has to come on now to try and inject something into our attack.
When you see Kelly the young lad come in a give such a mature performance defensively AND offensively you do wonder despite Johnson having a cracking start to his career, we could have allocated £17m to another striker / attacking midfielder who could have come on now to change this type of game.
Wow thats some knee-jerkery there. Tweedle in disguise?
Call it knee jerk, of course its only one performance, however you see on one side of our defence Insua who has come through and done well, however against better teams his obvious lack of experience has at times been shown. Tonight Kelly comes on and plays like a 28 year old full back - begs the question if he does this day in day out on the training field, having another young and talented right back in Johnson infront of him indicates hes unlikely to get loads of chances, so a wasted talent? no?
£17m could have been used in our much recognised poor strength in depth upfront, no?
He's 19. I don't get it you disprove your own argument in the same paragraph you push it. The example of Insua shows you are being silly. If Spearing has a couple of great games are you going to say we shouldn't have bought Aquilani?
Actually my arguement contradicts Benitez, he gives Insua an opportunity, yet not Kelly through buying Johnson?
Its a question of opportunity cost, we clearly lack quality in depth upfront - i'm saying £17m could give you a lot of options in the transfer market upfront.
I assume you would prefer to stifle young talent coming through at the expense of addressing other areas. I'm in no way saying Johnson has been a dissapointment, but when we are looking for goals like tonight i'd rather Benitez have bought some depth upfront and used youth like Kelly and balanced that risk for the benefit of the whole team.
From your opposition, i assume you think the likes of Babel, Voronin and co are Liverpool quality, and you were happy we signed no attacking players this summer?
No. I just think your logic is massively flawed. Had Rafa gambled on Kelly in the summer (he wasnt even that impressive in pre-season) then we would have rightly slagged him off. That has nothing to do with whether Johnson or Aquilani were better buys than a forward.
Don't spin your bullshit at me please btw - as if I want to stifle young talent or think those players are good enough for fucks sake.