by EMP Fri Sep 14, 2012 1:43 pm
Viva España wrote:EMP
Never existed King Jaume I of Catalunya.
First Cataluña never was a kingdom. Cataluña belonged to the Kingdom of Aragon.
The king was King Jaime I of Aragon.
Cataluña was never independent country or state. They want freedom but were never independent. They never were conquered or invaded by nobody like Ireland or Scotland.
So its a stranger type of freedom they proclaim.
Sorry for my bad English.
I think it depends on who you talk to.
http://www.barcelona-tourist-information.info/catalan-aragonese-empire.html
Of course they would say that, but the fact that the Catalan language was originally spoken in parts of empire is interesting. Question is what did he see himself as. Wouldn't Aragon have called him Jaime. Why is he known as Jaume I el Conquerador?
http://www.barcelona-tourist-information.info/jaume-I.html
This suggests that there were distinct parts of the Kingdom(s) and empire and that some at least saw it as a joint empire. I understand that they would say that, but it still raises the issue as do these:
http://www.alcudiamallorca.com/en/alcudia/the-conquest-by-king-jaume-i-creation-of-the-kingdom-of-mallorca-(year-1229).html
http://press.princeton.edu/titles/8407.html
http://www.racba.org/en/mostrarobra2.php?id=23019
The latter article refers to him as king of Catalunya and Aragon. I'm not saying that the perception is right, but plainly there is one that he was King of Catalunya as well as Aragon and he acquired more Kingdoms including Valencia.
Even the Wikipedia article referes to him as both Jaume and Jaime, so it depends on your prespective.
Last edited by EMP on Fri Sep 14, 2012 2:01 pm; edited 1 time in total