Pick of the bunch: Robin van Persie, who is busy reminding us that had the Dutchman been fit for more than 15 Premier League games last season, the Gunners could well have regained the title. Those may be ifs and buts, but the plain facts are that van Persie has scored eight goals in 15 league appearances this season and stellar performances against Chelsea and Liverpool suggest that he is no flat-track bully.
We expected more from...Cesc Fabregas, who has too often looked ordinary this season. It's not that he's playing terribly, it's just that he's not playing terribly well - leaving room for suggestions that Euro 2008 on the back of a long season have left the Spaniard needing a break. Alternatively, the loss of Mathieu Flamini has taken away his defensive safety net and given him too much responsibility. Either way, becoming captain will not ease the burden.
So we were wrong about...Alex Song. He's no Flamini, Lassana Diarra or even Gilberto, but he has been thrust into action as Arsene Wenger belatedly acknowledged that he needed a no-nonsense defensive midfielder and responded with some decent though rarely eye-catching performances, until he successfully kept Steven Gerrard quiet against Liverpool.
ASTON VILLA
Pick of the bunch: There's significant competition from Martin Laursen, Brad Friedel and Gaby Agbonlahor, but tiny head and shoulders above the rest is Ashley Young, whose pace is devastating and set-piece delivery is deadly. Boss Martin O'Neill has been mentioning him in the same breath as Lionel Messi and though that might be slightly premature, it's certainly not the laughable claim it may have been a year ago.
We expected more from...Nicky Shorey. Touted as the best left-back outside the Big Four last season, Shorey has been found out at Villa, suffering the ignominy of being dropped in favour of a career right-back.
So we were wrong about...Luke Young. In all honesty, we thought Young was a jobbing right-back, so imagine our surprise when he has excelled even out of position. An England recall will surely follow.
BLACKBURN
Pick of the bunch: It's probably more a case of 'who hasn't disgraced themselves this season', and that 'honour' goes to Stephen Warnock, whose decent form (in defence and midfield) amongst the mire has apparently attracted interest from Spurs and Newcastle. Decent of course if you ignore the mauling he got against Wigan, but this is Blackburn - we can't be picky.
We expected more from...pretty much everyone but mostly Roque Santa Cruz. After 19 Premier League goals last season came summer talk of moves to more glamorous pastures and the Paraguayan has clearly had his head turned - probably towards Manchester. His expected January exit will not be mourned if it brings £20m.
So we were wrong about...Benni McCarthy. He certainly seemed to have shot his bolt last season with a severe case of second-season syndrome and he slipped to fifth-choice striker status under Paul Ince. But he was irresistible against Stoke and with Santa Cruz on his way, he could be the man to save Rovers from the drop.
BOLTON
Pick of the bunch: Some may say Matthew Taylor but Gary Cahill has been the rock on which the Trotters' impressive form has been built. Cahill gets points for leaving Villa rather than sitting on a bench and he has been rewarded by talk of an England call and the chance of being involved in an unlikely top-half finish.
We expected more from...Kevin Nolan. Gary Megson's preferred 4-5-1 formation should - in theory - free up Nolan to score more goals, just as he did in previous seasons under Sam Allardyce, when he twice broke the double-figure barrier. That hasn't really happened for Nolan, who has ostensibly stood still over the last two years. Where are those 'Nolan for England' calls now?
So we were wrong about...Johan Elmander. Well, maybe not entirely wrong but he's hardly been the massive flop that was predicted. His first touch can be woeful but he is capable of some moments of brilliant finishing and is working hard in the notoriously difficult lone striker role.
CHELSEA
Pick of the bunch: There are three strong candidates but Nic Anelka and Frank Lampard have been put in the shade by Jose Bosingwa on the grounds that it is his first season in English football and he has been easily the best right-back in the Premier League. Probably doesn't know what 'bedding-in period' even means.
We expected more from...Deco. Well, we didn't expect too much before the season, but those opening games set the bar high. An injury lay-off followed and the Deco that returns has been a passenger in the Chelsea midfield, sparking rumours of unrest amongst his teammates, who are reportedly not fooled by his moment of brilliance against Bolton.
So we were wrong about...Nic Anelka. Seen in the summer as a massive mistake by Chelsea, who appeared to be lumbered with a sulky, non-scoring striker. Just the 14 league goals later, there are a lot of words being eaten around now.
EVERTON
Pick of the bunch: Phil Jagielka. Started the season in midfield and looked thoroughly out of his depth, but since moving back to central defence in partnership with Joseph Yobo he has been phenomenal, particularly in successive 1-0 wins against Bolton and Fulham. In a season when Joleon Lescott has disappointed, is Fabio picking the wrong Everton defender?
We expected more from...Lescott but also Mikel Arteta, who was comfortable in most people's lists of best XIs outside the Big Four, but the Spaniard has been underwhelming this season. There's still the danger from set-pieces but Toffees have come to expect more creativity from open play.
So we were wrong about...Marouane Fellaini. It looked like a panic buy from David Moyes on the final day of the transfer window and certainly the Belgian's early appearances did nothing to dispel the notion that he was far from Premier League material. But in recent weeks, there have been signs that his ridiculous height and hair are drawing attention away from a decent if not breathtaking footballer.
FULHAM
Pick of the bunch: The heart says Jimmy Bullard but the head says Brede Hangeland, who has been ridiculously good in the heart of a Cottagers' defence that is amongst the meanest in the league. Europe's top clubs are sending their scouts to Craven Cottage, and you can bet your life it's not for a curly-haired Seventies throwback.
We expected more from...It's tempting to say Andy Johnson, but who truly expected him to score a hatful? Instead the spotlight turns to Zoltan Gera, who has been somewhat left behind in the great Fulham revolution, with Clint Dempsey more often preferred on the left of midfield. Probably not what one of the Championship's most creative players expected when he jumped the West Brom ship for Fulham.
So we were wrong about...the whole team. Hands up who thought Fulham would be in the top half of the table at the turn of the year. Even Roy Hodgson has his hands in his pockets.
HULL CITY
Pick of the bunch: It has to be that man Geovanni, the summer's best free transfer by far. The Brazilian is not only a massive goal threat operating behind a lone frontman, but has learnt how to put in a shift under Phil Brown, who has proved he learned a thing or two about unlikely transfer swwops from Sam Allardyce at Bolton.
We expected more from...Let's face it, nobody. Expectations were low.
So we were wrong about...Marlon King. We make no apologies for writing pre-season that Hull had a paucity of attacking talent and cited the Wigan loanee as an example of a Championship striker, erm, punching above his weight. Five goals may not seem like a great return, but that's roughly four goals more than we suspected.
LIVERPOOL
Pick of the bunch: While Fernando Torres has been injured and Steven Gerrard somewhat below par, pressure has grown on the Liverpool defence to at least keep it tight. Captain of that ship is Jamie Carragher, who has been almost perfect this season, with particular credit due for his performance at Stamford Bridge, where he almost always excels.
WHAT? HELLO.... XABI ALONSO EASILY OUR PLAYER OF THE SEASON
We expected more from...Some might argue he's not had the opportunities, but it's been up to Ryan Babel to press his claims when he does come off the bench, and there has been little to suggest that he should displace Albert Riera. This was supposed to be the season he came of age...we're still waiting.
So we were wrong about...Dirk Kuyt, though to be fair we have been on the Dutchman's bandwagon for some time now. Like Emile Heskey, Kuyt is an easy player to denigrate but five Premier League goals from a midfield position and more miles covered that just about any other player are the only answers he needs to provide.
MANCHESTER CITY
Pick of the bunch: When things were going well for Manchester City, there was one man at the heart of everything creative - and it wasn't always Robinho. When things started to go badly, there was one man who appeared to be working his bollocks off. That man is Stephen Ireland. If only the rest of the team could say the same.
We expected more from...Richard Dunne and Micah Richards. They were supposed to be the best central defensive partnership outside of the very top echelons of the game. But they have looked too often this season like bumbling idiots and a January move for Matty Upson looks more and more likely by the day.
So we were wrong about...Robinho. In all honesty we thought he would be horrendous. We thought he would be arrogant, lazy and frankly too Bertie Big Bollocks for the Premier League. Instead he promptly scored six goals in his first six games and looked irresistible. It's early days but the Brazilian looks like as sound an investment as £30m can buy. Now they just have to buy a striker worthy of playing alongside him.[b]