Your teams all time XI

Who'd make it?

Who's be the noticeable absentee's?

Who'd be the manager?

Mine (from what I've read, discussed and seen)


-------------------- Schmeichel

Neville ------- Stam -------- Edwards ------ Irwin

Best --------- Keane -------- Robson ------ Giggs

---------------------- Charlton

------------------------ Law

Manager: Sir Matt Busby

Had to leave out Cantona, but I think all of the front 6 have done more for United. Also Sir Matt just has the edge on Fergie for building the club from scrath.

I'm not even going to try, what I will do is a first 11 for arsenal since I was about 8 though:

-------------------Seaman------------------

Dixon------Adams----Campbell-----Cole

Pires--------Vieira-----Petit-----Overmars

--------------Henry----Bergkamp--------

The surprise clearly being that Wright didn't make it!

@Parky,

which Edwards is that you've got as centre back?

Duncan Edwards.

One of the Busby Babes who died in '58.

Even Bobby Charlton said he was a class above.

Parks Lives wrote:Duncan Edwards.

One of the Busby Babes who died in '58.

Even Bobby Charlton said he was a class above.

Yeah, I heard the same thing from my grandad, but wasnt he a striker though? http://www.duncan-edwards.co.uk/apps/guestbook/guestbook.asp?PagePosition=41

He could play anywhere.

He often played in defence and its alot easier to leave someone out of the defence from our history than in midfield or up front.

The only other defenders I can think of are Foulkes, Bruce, Pallister, McGrath and Ferdinand.

Just seen a link saying he played at centre half, but would often end matches as a second striker. So that explains the confusion.

Apparently he was just awesome. As a non United fan its a big shame from an England perspective as he could have been a legend in the league of Beckenbauer, Pele, Cruyff, Maradonna et al.

According to the old man in my living room that is

Loads of people say he would of taken Moore's place in '66 (strange to think it wouldn't of been Jack Charlton's though).

-------------Preud'Home-------------
Veloso-Ricardo-Mozer-Vitor Paneira
Poborsky-Joao Pinto-Rui Costa-Schwartz
-----------Isaias---------------
---------------Eusebio----------

Subs- Bento, Humberto Coelho, Chalana, Paulo Sousa, Coluna, Jose Aguas, Thern, Simao, Valdo.
And some more that I can not start to think off

-------------------Given-------------------

------------Albert------Moncur------------

---------Lee-----Clark----Speed---------

-----------------Beardsley-----------------

Milburn--Gallacher--Shearer--Macdonald


Manager: Kevin Keegan

Screw defence.

I've had to leave out the likes of Asprilla, Mirandinha, McDermott, Shackleton, and Ferdinand. Too many strikers.

lampiao007 wrote:-------------Preud'Home-------------
Veloso-Ricardo-Mozer-Vitor Paneira
Poborsky-Joao Pinto-Rui Costa-Schwartz
-----------Isaias---------------
---------------Eusebio----------

Subs- Bento, Humberto Coelho, Chalana, Paulo Sousa, Coluna, Jose Aguas, Thern, Simao, Valdo.
And some more that I can not start to think off

No Dean Saunders or Michael Thomas?

The Real White Pele wrote:

lampiao007 wrote:-------------Preud'Home-------------
Veloso-Ricardo-Mozer-Vitor Paneira
Poborsky-Joao Pinto-Rui Costa-Schwartz
-----------Isaias---------------
---------------Eusebio----------

Subs- Bento, Humberto Coelho, Chalana, Paulo Sousa, Coluna, Jose Aguas, Thern, Simao, Valdo.
And some more that I can not start to think off

No Dean Saunders or Michael Thomas?

I almost got Brian Deane in there , altough Scott Minto did play a few good games
And Dean Saunders was almost a legend in Portugal.The guy scored a few crackers (so did Brian Dean against Porto and Sporting )

Repeated thread (if I recall I even kept in home PC the starting eleven I've chosen).

So this time, instead of all time, I do it only "Since the 90's".

Schmeichel

C. Xavier André Cruz Luisinho Rui Jorge

Figo Paulo Sousa Balacov Ronaldo

Jardel Liedson

Subs: Ivkovic, Ricardo Rocha, Marco Aurélio, Oceano, Futre, Quaresma, Pedro Barbosa, João Vieira Pinto, Acosta

Coach: Mirko Jozic

The last one, was the top 5 players who've played for your club.

the all time eleven was either in 606 version, or the first board.

Tonny van Leeuwen

Adri van Tiggelen - Ronald Koeman - Jan Van Dijk

Piet Fransen - Fandhi Ahmed - Erwin Koeman - Arjen Robben

Harris Huizingh

Hennie Meyer - Milko Djurovski


Bench : Peter Houtman, Rene Eijkelkamp, Patrick Lodewijks, Mariano Bombarda , John de Wolf

- - - - - - - Clemence
Neal - Hansen - Lawerson - Kennedy
Heighway - Souness - McDermott - Barnes
- - - - - - - Rush - Dalglish


Notable abstentees:
Keegan, Nicol, Thompson, Yeats, Hunt, Grobbelar, Toshak etc etc etc.

---------KAHN

Sagnol---Linke---Helmer---Lizarazu

------------Matthäus
Basler-------------------Scholl
------------Effenberg


---Klinsmann----Elber


my favourite alltime 11

Deisler wrote:---------KAHN

Sagnol---Linke---Helmer---Lizarazu

------------Matthäus
Basler-------------------Scholl
------------Effenberg


---Klinsmann----Elber


my favourite alltime 11

crap team

Deisler wrote:---------KAHN

Sagnol---Linke---Helmer---Lizarazu

------------Matthäus
Basler-------------------Scholl
------------Effenberg


---Klinsmann----Elber


my favourite alltime 11

A Bayern all time XI without Beckenbauer, Breitner, Rummenigge and Müller? Impossible.


You may be too young to actually have seen them play, but it still is an affront.

You have to remember chrissicross that Deisler thinks that Podolski is better than Messi

I have no idea about how good Bolton were ages ago, so I'll have mine since I've started watching them!:

---------------Jussi

N'Gotty----Bergsson-Laville--Gardner

---------------Hierro--Campo

------Diouf-------------------Okocha
---------------Ricketts---Djorkaeff.


No place for my favourite player in the world, KD.

No Speed???

Someone more knowledgeable post Barca's and Real Madrid's please. I bet they are incredible.

Owen Thomas wrote:Someone more knowledgeable post Barca's and Real Madrid's please. I bet they are incredible.

as much as it pains me to say it their B teams would beat most A teams

Tweedledum wrote:You have to remember chrissicross that Deisler thinks that Podolski is better than Messi

Can't compare them, completely different players. Podolski is one of the most clinical German strikers ever, he has everything to become a true great, he already has scored more goals for the Mannschaft than anyone else before him at his age (yes, even more than the great Gerd Müller). Messi is a huge talent, more of a attacking allrounder than a striker, technically already one of the best players in the world, pacy and a good footballing brain.

If both continue to improve like they did in the last few years, they'll be amongst the very best players in the world on their positions in near future.

CFC team (from my lifetime):

---------------Cech---------------
----Gallas---Terry---Desailly----
------------Makelele--------------
-----Poyet--Wise--Di Matteo-----
--------------Gullit-----------------
-----Gudjohnsen---Zola-----------

I know Gullit joined us in his mid 30s, obviously not at his best, but he was a great player to watch (even at that age).

Kimbo wrote:No Speed???

Nope, Hierro and Campo>Speed.

it took me 1 hour to build this team, and i'm still not sure

----------------------------------Zubizarreta---------------------------

------------ Neeskens------------Koeman--------------Miqueli

-----Laudrup--------- Schuster--------- Guardiola-------Suarez-------

-------------------------------------Cruyff -----------------------------

------------------------ Kubala------------------- Cesar-------------



Subs.
Dinho
Hagi
Romario
Stoitchkov
Rexach
Bakero
Ramallets

Manager- Rinus Michels

sinca i few people where say Mara didn't play long enough i have made a few changes.

at least this was Suarez can get to play in his right postion.