Well i don't think it's right that one of our players gets borrowed and put out of action for a year losing us millions. The FA and FIFA earn millions from borrowing our players for their crappy internationals, IMO it's only right that they pay for the wages of players that get injured while under their care.Luso wrote:Kimbo wrote:If you made your case to FIFA then you would. I don't see why Newcastle would be a special case, we're not a G14 club.Luso wrote:
*Still don't think you should get a cent. Again, if Ricardo had gone down we'd be out our #1 keeper and have nothing to show for it.
But you're British...
Porto wouldn't get shit either and they're orignal G14.
I know you guys think FIFA/UEFA hate you, and they might, but you're loaded and they know they need to keep rich clubs/leagues happy.
It's nothing against Newcastle really, I actually don't mind your club, but I still don't think it's right.
+7
Lordanger
Luso
Tweesus
AsianBoy
fcb
Owen Thomas
Kimbo
11 posters
When Did the Times Become Bullshit Merchants?
Kimbo- Number of posts : 38171
Registration date : 2006-08-06
Luso- Number of posts : 3305
Age : 113
Supports : Sporting Clube de Portugal
Registration date : 2006-08-07
Chap wrote:Owen only joined to play at the WC in the first team, so he was never going to say no - and if Newcastle tried to stop him they'd screw up their relationship with him and end up selling him at a big loss. Its tough on them, and the Times article is crap, but they shouldn't be compensated. The situation is more a result of Owens' individual case than of FIFA rules forcing their hand.
I totally agree with you, everyone knows your first two statements to be true. But that's Newcastle's problem. Shouldn't be anyone's but theirs.
Luso- Number of posts : 3305
Age : 113
Supports : Sporting Clube de Portugal
Registration date : 2006-08-07
Kimbo wrote:Well i don't think it's right that one of our players gets borrowed and put out of action for a year losing us millions. The FA and FIFA earn millions from borrowing our players for their crappy internationals, IMO it's only right that they pay for the wages of players that get injured while under their care.Luso wrote:Kimbo wrote:If you made your case to FIFA then you would. I don't see why Newcastle would be a special case, we're not a G14 club.Luso wrote:
*Still don't think you should get a cent. Again, if Ricardo had gone down we'd be out our #1 keeper and have nothing to show for it.
But you're British...
Porto wouldn't get shit either and they're orignal G14.
I know you guys think FIFA/UEFA hate you, and they might, but you're loaded and they know they need to keep rich clubs/leagues happy.
It's nothing against Newcastle really, I actually don't mind your club, but I still don't think it's right.
In theory, I agree with you. When Sporting players get hurt playing for Portugal, I get pissed. We end up without our own players that WE pay, no one else. The FPF should be compensating us, just as you've mentioned. I don't know about FIFA...although they're in the best shape to do so.
That isn't the case though, so I'm not sure why Newcaslte getting this allowance. However, maybe you're setting a trend, and in that sense I'd support that as it would help us out too.
BTW the FA is better than the FPF that actually deprived Sporting of Hugo Viana and Ricardo Quaresma a few seasons back in the Uefa cup against Milan. They had to play some match for Portugal while Sporting, that actually paid their salaries, wasn't able to use it's own players in Italy...the FPF said they would gain experience playing for the sub-20 or sub-21 which ever it was... fucks!
Lordanger- Number of posts : 1519
Age : 46
Supports : hairbands
Favourite Player : Not Gerrard
Registration date : 2006-09-27
please dont bring religion (or lack of it) into it: the two shouldn't mix!!!
leave religion to your granny!!
leave religion to your granny!!
Saintsar- Guest
ih8gerrard wrote:please dont bring religion (or lack of it) into it: the two shouldn't mix!!!
leave religion to your granny!!
Yeah, like wow, y'know, atheism is cool, y'know, religion is brainwashing...
Have you got anything interesting to say?
Roger Hunt- Number of posts : 10115
Age : 54
Registration date : 2006-08-07
Kimbo wrote:
Well i don't think it's right that one of our players gets borrowed and put out of action for a year losing us millions. The FA and FIFA earn millions from borrowing our players for their crappy internationals, IMO it's only right that they pay for the wages of players that get injured while under their care.
I agree with your point in principle Kimbo.
But as I've said before, you overpaid for a player who had a history of serious injuries and putting country before club, so to a large extent you've made a rod for your own backs.
Luso- Number of posts : 3305
Age : 113
Supports : Sporting Clube de Portugal
Registration date : 2006-08-07
ih8gerrard wrote:please dont bring religion (or lack of it) into it: the two shouldn't mix!!!
leave religion to your granny!!
Who's mixing religion with anything?
Humour evades you doesn't it?
I'll be sure to pray for you tonight.