by Kimbo Sat Jan 26, 2013 2:17 pm
Disco Benny wrote: Kimbo wrote:We're getting so much stick for signing foreign players.
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sport/football/article-2267338/Newcastle-producing-local-Toon-talent-foreign-legion-Jamie-Redknapp.html?ito=feeds-newsxml
If it's a choice between getting relegated with a team of overpaid Englishmen(again) or filling the team with foreigners and staying up, i'd pick the latter. And all this shit about how people hoping we get relegated, Newcastle are supposed to be a traditional club etc, people were hoping we got relegated when we had a team of Englishmen, most would enjoy seeing us relegated no matter what the clubs circumstances are. There isn't a single English player in our squad that I would be upset to see leave.
That's actually not a bad article. Its not a xenophobic rant, there is definitely a question there to ask why Newcastle is producing so few local talents- the point about your u18s team being so poor despite the investment made under John Hall into the academy in the 90s is interesting.
It is possible to be successful recruiting English talent without spending huge amounts on ridiculous wages. We had 8 Englishman against United on the weekend and outplayed them, none of those 8 actually came through our (currently very successful) academy yet none bought for or on silly money. I know Newcastle aren't in the same financial position we are, but then 5-6 years ago they were. The misfortune of having a succession of crap owners I guess.
We don't produce British talent because we're a British team.
I don't know why we used to produce good players, but times have changed and now we're the same as everywhere else in the country. British people in general are devoid of flair, that's why our Rugby team have always played a gritty physical style, Andy Murray is our tennis player rather than Federer, guys like Froch and Calzaghe are our top boxers rather than Jones Jr and Whitaker. I mean people here think Rooney is skillful, I was watching a Peter Beardsley compilation yesterday and the two are on different planets, we'll probably never produce a player like that again. I can't think of 1 really skillful current English player. People in this country think Steven "40 yard pass/shot" Gerrard is a great player, we're fucked!
It would be nice to produce local players, but in terms of English ones, I feel no more connection to a cockney like Jamie Redknapp than I do a french player, why would I?! As for the local players we do produce, Steven "Mr Geordie" Taylor was refusing to sign a new contract if we didn't meet his wages demands, so in the end he got a 40k a week contract, twice what he deserves and probably more than what Mbiwa is getting, I would've let him go. So what is the benefit of bringing through local players? They're no more loyal than foreign players, and they'll use their status as "local" boys to get bigger contracts.
Also how many teams recently sold an academy product for £35m, and how many have played as many academy products as Newcastle this season? We've given our young players a chance this season, but they're not good enough, because they're British, so we have no choice but to buy foreign. I really don't think it's fair to single out Newcastle when the entire country is failing. Maybe if we had signed Zaha for £15m rather than 3 France internationals for the same amount we would get some credit.