by Bashmachkin Tue Oct 23, 2007 2:37 pm
It was a very good performance from Butt. I thought he, along with the centre backs, were very solid. Butt made a number of excellent challenges and covered the pitch well too. Id still contest his man of the match award, though he seems an ever-popular man of the match awardee, standing as he does for commitment and being considered one of the most experienced of our players - he often wins the award when the team as a whole dont play well, whereas last night I thought we had some good patches of play, though the way we stood off at times, particularly in the second half, allowed Butt to do what hes best at. And like I say, he broke up the play really well. Personally Id have given the man of the match award to Martins, because for me, his goal won us the game - it came from his own determination, hed threatened a few times before that point and was our only outlet in attack throughout, the finish was good, hes probably the only player in our team who could have scored the goal, and in the end, after a mediocre first half overall, the goal was vital in establishing our superiority.
I did think there were some promising signs from last night, as well as a good result. Whilst Id still play Rozehnal at the back, probably along with Faye, its clear that we now have a very good choice of players at centre back. Both Faye and Cacapa are very strong defensively. And the full backs, despite poor delivery at times, overlapped pretty well, Enrique made one or two forays later on, Beye was strong in the tackle. Butt and Emre, whilst Emre was far from exceptional, at least worked better as a partnership in my opinion - Butt and Geremi, what with Geremis lack of mobility, always looks too static and uncreative, whilst they dont seem to communicate or compliment each other naturally. Geremi was poor, N'Zogbia improved through the first half and was starting to make some good runs down the left, and should have stayed on the pitch. Owen, however good he is at what he does, doesnt do enough, and certainly not enough for us. He stands high up the pitch and, when we dont have the ball all of the time, and dont always build moves, he doesnt get involved in the play but just hovers around.
Overall, like I say, I think at least indications of a more balanced team throughout.