Would you like to react to this message? Create an account in a few clicks or log in to continue.

+22
christmasborocooper
Deano
Kimbo
Glenarch of the Glen
Calidad
The-Frank-Tavern
Deluded F*ck™
DD
Yef
Isco Benny
debaser
S4P
Sheffield gunner
Bashmachkin
110%
toon h
lrdsucksgoats
Parks lives
Axeslammer
Puro
Sgoater1
Chocolate Thunder
26 posters

    Worst Signing of the Season

    Chocolate Thunder
    Chocolate Thunder


    Number of posts : 15804
    Age : 37
    Supports : Borussia Dortmund and Liverpool
    Registration date : 2007-01-06

    Worst Signing of the Season Empty Worst Signing of the Season

    Post by Chocolate Thunder Mon May 05, 2008 2:05 am

    Who have been the biggest waste of space/flop/pointless signing of 07/08?

    Worst Signing of the Season 0,5001,5631085,00

    Is it this lovely chap ^

    or

    Worst Signing of the Season 21431_hp

    13.5 million pounds Moussier Malouda ^

    or

    Worst Signing of the Season 21767_news

    16.5 million pounds just to sit on the bench, Darren Bent


    Can you name someone else?, be my guest.


    Last edited by Ade Mascherano on Mon May 05, 2008 2:13 am; edited 1 time in total
    Sgoater1
    Sgoater1


    Number of posts : 11129
    Age : 41
    Supports : Man City
    Registration date : 2006-08-06

    Worst Signing of the Season Empty Re: Worst Signing of the Season

    Post by Sgoater1 Mon May 05, 2008 2:12 am

    Kaboul !
    Puro
    Puro


    Number of posts : 10679
    Registration date : 2006-09-12

    Worst Signing of the Season Empty Re: Worst Signing of the Season

    Post by Puro Mon May 05, 2008 2:27 am

    Taking into account that Owen didn't play much last season, I consider him like a new signing. Furthermore, base on what Newcastle spent to get him, his salary and what the team got in performances, he, by far has given a team the worst returns of them all. Someone (forgot what newspaper) wrote that Newcastle have wasted all in all over 35 million pounds on his ass. And, we hear that Newcastle want to reward him with a new contract. Laugh

    Imagine if Michael Owen were a Johnny Foreigner pulling the same stunt or a black Englishman like say Defoe. His ass would've been shipped out a long time ago. Must be nice being Owen in England. I'd ride that too to the last cent if I were Owen, AND had imbeciles running a football club.

    Marcus Bent from Wigan, Dave Kitson from Reading, Boro's Tuncay, West Ham's Ashton, B'gham's Forsell... give you comparable results AND you won't have to waste "Owen" cash on them. Biggrin <Ale>

    Owen BY FAR, BY A COUNTRY MILE the worst signing. True story! <Ale>
    Axeslammer
    Axeslammer


    Number of posts : 19690
    Age : 52
    Supports : Leeds Utd / FC Groningen
    Favourite Player : Le Tiss, Bergkamp, Tadic, Eric le Roy
    Registration date : 2006-08-07

    Worst Signing of the Season Empty Re: Worst Signing of the Season

    Post by Axeslammer Mon May 05, 2008 5:13 am

    I didn't expect anything from Darren Bent, but pound for pound he's been the biggest joke.

    The biggest deception for me was Malouda : I expected a lot from him...
    avatar
    Parks lives


    Number of posts : 34521
    Age : 43
    Favourite Player : The Ginger One
    Registration date : 2006-08-06

    Worst Signing of the Season Empty Re: Worst Signing of the Season

    Post by Parks lives Mon May 05, 2008 6:43 am

    Malouda.
    lrdsucksgoats
    lrdsucksgoats


    Number of posts : 9523
    Age : 82
    Supports : Decentralisation of the state
    Favourite Player : The lesser spotted Ronaldo
    Registration date : 2007-02-25

    Worst Signing of the Season Empty Re: Worst Signing of the Season

    Post by lrdsucksgoats Mon May 05, 2008 7:18 am

    Puro wrote:Taking into account that Owen didn't play much last season, I consider him like a new signing. Furthermore, base on what Newcastle spent to get him, his salary and what the team got in performances, he, by far has given a team the worst returns of them all. Someone (forgot what newspaper) wrote that Newcastle have wasted all in all over 35 million pounds on his ass. And, we hear that Newcastle want to reward him with a new contract. Laugh

    Imagine if Michael Owen were a Johnny Foreigner pulling the same stunt or a black Englishman like say Defoe. His ass would've been shipped out a long time ago. Must be nice being Owen in England. I'd ride that too to the last cent if I were Owen, AND had imbeciles running a football club.

    Marcus Bent from Wigan, Dave Kitson from Reading, Boro's Tuncay, West Ham's Ashton, B'gham's Forsell... give you comparable results AND you won't have to waste "Owen" cash on them. Biggrin <Ale>

    Owen BY FAR, BY A COUNTRY MILE the worst signing. True story! <Ale>


    Racist. If Newcastle weren't run by morons and supported by uncritical obsessives then it'd be different.
    toon h
    toon h


    Number of posts : 8715
    Age : 51
    Supports : FC Barcelona
    Registration date : 2006-08-07

    Worst Signing of the Season Empty Re: Worst Signing of the Season

    Post by toon h Mon May 05, 2008 8:33 am

    Henry - by a mile.
    avatar
    110%


    Number of posts : 8978
    Age : 50
    Registration date : 2006-08-07

    Worst Signing of the Season Empty Re: Worst Signing of the Season

    Post by 110% Mon May 05, 2008 9:15 am

    if owen's goals have helped newcastle avoid relegation then that's saved them 30 million pounds as well

    am I right in saying that bent cost more than henry? and barca will have made a lot of that back in shirt sales as well, but who would buy a shirt which says bent on the back apart from tweeds Wink
    Bashmachkin
    Bashmachkin


    Number of posts : 2374
    Age : 38
    Registration date : 2007-02-09

    Worst Signing of the Season Empty Re: Worst Signing of the Season

    Post by Bashmachkin Mon May 05, 2008 9:19 am

    Puro - Owen has scored more goals than all of those players, after coming back from a long term injury.

    I'm not his biggest fan, and he certainly hasn't given us value for money in his time at the club so far. At times he has looked disinterested, focused more on England than on Newcastle - at one point earlier in the season, just before Christmas, in his two and a bit years at the club he had played more games for England than he'd played for us. I think he would get more criticism if he wasn't England's goalscorer. Many Newcastle fans seem to presume that Owen is more important to the team, more of a complete player, than Martins is, which I don't agree with in the slightest. And there's a sense to which people seem to feel that we need to keep him happy, whereas for most players it's the other way around.

    However, under Keegan, and playing in a withdrawn role, Owen has been a fundamental part of our resurgent team. He has captained us well, scored important goals, and most importantly he looks happier and has genuinely worked on the pitch. In the role he is playing now, he adds a lot to the team - he gets back and defends, and his distribution is very good, whilst he still makes runs from deep so as to be on the end of the chances we create. If some criticism is valid, then at the same time it is important that he has turned things around recently. And obviously he in no way counts as the worst signing of the season. For instance, Darren Bent cost a similar amount of money, is supposedly on a similar wage, and has scored four fewer goals in the Premiership.
    avatar
    Sheffield gunner


    Number of posts : 16403
    Age : 39
    Supports : Arsenal
    Registration date : 2006-08-07

    Worst Signing of the Season Empty Re: Worst Signing of the Season

    Post by Sheffield gunner Mon May 05, 2008 9:24 am

    Litmanen, if he is being paid £15,000 a week as some papers are reporting. He was brought in to help save Fulham from relegation, but he hasn't played once, despite making appearances for Finland during this period, and he keeps missing games with bizarre injuries. A complete waste of time for the Fulham fans by the sound of it.
    Bashmachkin
    Bashmachkin


    Number of posts : 2374
    Age : 38
    Registration date : 2007-02-09

    Worst Signing of the Season Empty Re: Worst Signing of the Season

    Post by Bashmachkin Mon May 05, 2008 9:31 am

    Personally, I think that Martins has been the most instrumental player in terms of saving us from relegation, in both this season and last season. Our worst run of form this season coincided largely with his absence due to the African Nation of Cups, though our recovery this year has been a team effort. Last season, Martins' goals were crucial in a team that lacked any other firepower.

    On the subject at hand, I think Malouda has been one of the most disappointing signings of the season, and poor value for money, though I'm not sure he's been the worst signing overall. It felt as though he would come in and adapt straight away, and he hasn't done that, and he looks slow. I don't think Bent is a bad player, but he was hugely overpriced considering the role he has played at Tottenham this season. Voronin obviously isn't great, but from that photo, McShane gave a performance a few weeks ago against us in which he looked entirely out of his depth, should have been sent off, with an own goal to his name, within the first half. Kieron Dyer cost West Ham £7 million and has played two games for them this season, and from that perspective, he has been perhaps the worst value for money. He is a quality player, but he's never fit - West Ham were unwise in signing him and Bellamy. For Newcastle, Smith and Barton, £6 million each, are two of the worst players I've ever seen at the club.
    S4P
    S4P


    Number of posts : 14358
    Age : 44
    Supports : Chelsea
    Registration date : 2007-03-24

    Worst Signing of the Season Empty Re: Worst Signing of the Season

    Post by S4P Mon May 05, 2008 10:09 am

    Given his first 3 performances, you have to say Malouda was the biggest let down. However, I think he's done enough not to be considered the worst signing.

    He'll be better next season though.
    debaser
    debaser


    Number of posts : 22064
    Age : 39
    Supports : Aston Villa and Shrewsbury Town
    Registration date : 2006-08-08

    Worst Signing of the Season Empty Re: Worst Signing of the Season

    Post by debaser Mon May 05, 2008 10:14 am

    Bent and Malouda the 2 most expensive failures, but there's a fair few contenders for this crown:

    Nugent at £6m was pretty horrendous, considering they wanted to sell him within a month of signing him.

    Bianchi didn't pay off, either (8 or 9m, I think)

    Then in the Sunderland department, they signed a plethora of players in the 2-3m bracket that seem completely wasteful. Greg Halford, my particular favourite.

    And finally....Alan 'play me and you lose, drop me and you win' Smith is in a £6m world of his own.
    Isco Benny
    Isco Benny


    Number of posts : 19647
    Age : 44
    Supports : Spurs, FOLLOWS (just for worms): Werder Bremen, Lazio, Ferencvaros, Valencia, El Classico, Angleterre, Magyarorszag
    Favourite Player : Don't cha wish your left back was BAE? Don't cha
    Registration date : 2006-08-08

    Worst Signing of the Season Empty Re: Worst Signing of the Season

    Post by Isco Benny Mon May 05, 2008 11:15 am

    Puro wrote:Taking into account that Owen didn't play much last season, I consider him like a new signing. Furthermore, base on what Newcastle spent to get him, his salary and what the team got in performances, he, by far has given a team the worst returns of them all. Someone (forgot what newspaper) wrote that Newcastle have wasted all in all over 35 million pounds on his ass. And, we hear that Newcastle want to reward him with a new contract. Laugh

    Imagine if Michael Owen were a Johnny Foreigner pulling the same stunt or a black Englishman like say Defoe. His ass would've been shipped out a long time ago. Must be nice being Owen in England. I'd ride that too to the last cent if I were Owen, AND had imbeciles running a football club.

    Marcus Bent from Wigan, Dave Kitson from Reading, Boro's Tuncay, West Ham's Ashton, B'gham's Forsell... give you comparable results AND you won't have to waste "Owen" cash on them. Biggrin <Ale>

    Owen BY FAR, BY A COUNTRY MILE the worst signing. True story! <Ale>

    scratch

    Since Fat Sa left and Newcastle starting playing proper football, OWen has scored something like 8 or 9 goals in 11 games

    Once again you are talking out of your arse. Excellent stuff <Ale>
    S4P
    S4P


    Number of posts : 14358
    Age : 44
    Supports : Chelsea
    Registration date : 2007-03-24

    Worst Signing of the Season Empty Re: Worst Signing of the Season

    Post by S4P Mon May 05, 2008 11:17 am

    Hasn't Owen been at Newcastle for 3-4 years now too?
    avatar
    Yef


    Number of posts : 2619
    Registration date : 2008-02-27

    Worst Signing of the Season Empty Re: Worst Signing of the Season

    Post by Yef Mon May 05, 2008 11:19 am

    Graeme Murty?
    avatar
    Guest
    Guest


    Worst Signing of the Season Empty Re: Worst Signing of the Season

    Post by Guest Mon May 05, 2008 11:29 am

    In terms of shitness Voronin by a distance, but he was free so I'm going to say Malouda. I still think Bent will come good, maybe not at Tottenham though.
    DD
    DD


    Number of posts : 10721
    Age : 44
    Supports : NEC
    Registration date : 2006-08-07

    Worst Signing of the Season Empty Re: Worst Signing of the Season

    Post by DD Mon May 05, 2008 11:39 am

    Possible contenders: 'Ghetto Kid' Prince Boateng, Pizarro, Nugent, Bianchi
    Axeslammer
    Axeslammer


    Number of posts : 19690
    Age : 52
    Supports : Leeds Utd / FC Groningen
    Favourite Player : Le Tiss, Bergkamp, Tadic, Eric le Roy
    Registration date : 2006-08-07

    Worst Signing of the Season Empty Re: Worst Signing of the Season

    Post by Axeslammer Mon May 05, 2008 11:44 am

    toon h wrote:Henry - by a mile.

    How can he be a disappointment if he was never any good to begin with...
    Deluded F*ck™
    Deluded F*ck™


    Number of posts : 21765
    Age : 38
    Supports : The Lilywhites from N17
    Favourite Player : The Hurrikane - he's on of our own!
    Registration date : 2006-08-07

    Worst Signing of the Season Empty Re: Worst Signing of the Season

    Post by Deluded F*ck™ Mon May 05, 2008 11:51 am

    Axeslammer wrote:
    toon h wrote:Henry - by a mile.

    How can he be a disappointment if he was never any good on a big pitch to begin with...

    okAle

    Torres ?
    The-Frank-Tavern
    The-Frank-Tavern


    Number of posts : 8505
    Age : 55
    Supports : Atlético de Madrid
    Registration date : 2006-08-07

    Worst Signing of the Season Empty Re: Worst Signing of the Season

    Post by The-Frank-Tavern Mon May 05, 2008 12:02 pm

    simple really Robbie Fowler
    avatar
    110%


    Number of posts : 8978
    Age : 50
    Registration date : 2006-08-07

    Worst Signing of the Season Empty Re: Worst Signing of the Season

    Post by 110% Mon May 05, 2008 12:18 pm

    DD wrote:Possible contenders: 'Ghetto Kid' Prince Boateng, Pizarro, Nugent, Bianchi

    good call on pizzaro

    far bigger wages than litmanen who someone else mentioned and done about the same
    Calidad
    Calidad


    Number of posts : 7996
    Age : 38
    Supports : Hibernian FC
    Registration date : 2006-08-25

    Worst Signing of the Season Empty Re: Worst Signing of the Season

    Post by Calidad Mon May 05, 2008 12:36 pm

    I said Malouda would flop before he arrived. Never been a fan really.

    I would say Bent
    toon h
    toon h


    Number of posts : 8715
    Age : 51
    Supports : FC Barcelona
    Registration date : 2006-08-07

    Worst Signing of the Season Empty Re: Worst Signing of the Season

    Post by toon h Mon May 05, 2008 12:47 pm

    Axeslammer wrote:
    toon h wrote:Henry - by a mile.

    How can he be a disappointment if he was never any good to begin with...

    the thread title says: worst signing.

    he wasn't really a disappointment, I must admit. After all his shite after the CL final against us (and France-Spain at the WC), we should never even have entertained the idea anymore.
    avatar
    Glenarch of the Glen


    Number of posts : 30157
    Age : 38
    Supports : Palestine
    Favourite Player : Hélder Barbosa
    Registration date : 2006-08-06

    Worst Signing of the Season Empty Re: Worst Signing of the Season

    Post by Glenarch of the Glen Mon May 05, 2008 12:47 pm

    Jermaine Jenis ok
    Sgoater1
    Sgoater1


    Number of posts : 11129
    Age : 41
    Supports : Man City
    Registration date : 2006-08-06

    Worst Signing of the Season Empty Re: Worst Signing of the Season

    Post by Sgoater1 Mon May 05, 2008 1:43 pm

    debaser wrote:Bent and Malouda the 2 most expensive failures, but there's a fair few contenders for this crown:

    Nugent at £6m was pretty horrendous, considering they wanted to sell him within a month of signing him.

    Bianchi didn't pay off, either (8 or 9m, I think)
    Then in the Sunderland department, they signed a plethora of players in the 2-3m bracket that seem completely wasteful. Greg Halford, my particular favourite.

    And finally....Alan 'play me and you lose, drop me and you win' Smith is in a £6m world of his own.


    The thing is with Bianchi is that he actually did well for us he just didnt settle in England. His record was 5 goals from 7 starts so tbh its a bit unfair to call him a flop. Also at the end of the season we will sell him and make a £1m profit.
    debaser
    debaser


    Number of posts : 22064
    Age : 39
    Supports : Aston Villa and Shrewsbury Town
    Registration date : 2006-08-08

    Worst Signing of the Season Empty Re: Worst Signing of the Season

    Post by debaser Mon May 05, 2008 1:56 pm

    Sgoater1 wrote:The thing is with Bianchi is that he actually did well for us he just didnt settle in England. His record was 5 goals from 7 starts so tbh its a bit unfair to call him a flop. Also at the end of the season we will sell him and make a £1m profit.
    okay, he wasn't an out-and-out flop like Nugent. I was meaning more in the 'return-compared-to-outlay' sense, he was a disappointment, albeit more for personal reasons than footballing ones.

    if you make profit, you'll have done pretty well on that deal..
    Sgoater1
    Sgoater1


    Number of posts : 11129
    Age : 41
    Supports : Man City
    Registration date : 2006-08-06

    Worst Signing of the Season Empty Re: Worst Signing of the Season

    Post by Sgoater1 Mon May 05, 2008 2:07 pm

    debaser wrote:
    Sgoater1 wrote:The thing is with Bianchi is that he actually did well for us he just didnt settle in England. His record was 5 goals from 7 starts so tbh its a bit unfair to call him a flop. Also at the end of the season we will sell him and make a £1m profit.
    okay, he wasn't an out-and-out flop like Nugent. I was meaning more in the 'return-compared-to-outlay' sense, he was a disappointment, albeit more for personal reasons than footballing ones.

    if you make profit, you'll have done pretty well on that deal..


    Yeah agree with you from that point of view, its a shame cos he could have done really well and scored arond 15 goals if he had settled.
    Kimbo
    Kimbo


    Number of posts : 38171
    Registration date : 2006-08-06

    Worst Signing of the Season Empty Re: Worst Signing of the Season

    Post by Kimbo Mon May 05, 2008 2:12 pm

    Worst Signing of the Season Alan-Smith-signs-for-Newcastle-United_514471

    Almost 100% of people think he's one of the least talented players we've seen at the club. There was a vote on the nufc forum about the worst Newcastle players in recent times, out of a shortlist of 50 odd, the list was reduced to 5, Smith was one of them. He was there along with Ramage, Amdy Faye, Babayaro, and Matty Pattison who i think won. There were only a handful of votes separating them though, it was very close.
    Sgoater1
    Sgoater1


    Number of posts : 11129
    Age : 41
    Supports : Man City
    Registration date : 2006-08-06

    Worst Signing of the Season Empty Re: Worst Signing of the Season

    Post by Sgoater1 Mon May 05, 2008 2:20 pm

    Oh yeah i forgot about Smith. WIthout doubt the biggest flop, £7m and he couldnt score in a brothel.

    Sponsored content


    Worst Signing of the Season Empty Re: Worst Signing of the Season

    Post by Sponsored content


      Current date/time is Fri Nov 01, 2024 4:22 pm