Scotland vs France

Can anybody do a rating of players .

Napoléon wrote:

italian_hammer(DEANO!) wrote:HAHAHAHA!

I don't think it's a so good news for you, mate...

Well it kind of is mate...If we take all our points from Scotland...we can be back in with a group winning shout....I cant see Scotland qualifying

Gordon was so good. Talk about a commited keeper

Coupet - 6- Nopthing to do, can't do anything about the goal
Abidal - 8 - Kept the Scottish forward man in check.
Boumsong - 7 - Dominated McFadden, but where is he on the corner.
Thuram- 8- Solid
Sagnol- 7- Had nothing to do, but didn't get up enough.
Ribery - 2 - Utter rubbish
Makélélé - 8 - excellent again
Vieira - 8 - One goal unjustly ruled out for offside
Malouda - 7 - Got forward well, had one very good shot saved
Henry - 9 - DId everything but score
Trez - 5 - Got one chance which was debatedly ruled out for offside. Otherwise very quiet.

Ribery shit again??

WHERE is Arnaud????

BilalShah wrote:Can anybody do a rating of players .

Ok let's go (french rating) :

Coupet 5,5 nothing to do. Can't do nothing on the goal.
Boumsong 5,5 some mistakes but easy game against just one forward
Thuram 5,5 same than boum
Abidal 5 could had done more forward
Sagnol 5,5 some good passes
Makélélé 6 good game, he's the master of midfield
Vieira 5,5 same than Maké but he did a mistake on the goal
Ribery 4 Bad game for him, we didn't see nothing of his talent
Malouda 5 Average
Henry 5 lose so many opportunities to score at the end
Trez 4 did nothing

Why Boumsoung starts for France?
And Scottish ratings too.

BilalShah wrote:Why Boumsoung starts for France?
And Scottish ratings too.

Everyone 3, except an 8 for Gordon.

theflyingfrenchman wrote:

BilalShah wrote:Why Boumsoung starts for France?
And Scottish ratings too.

Everyone 3, except an 8 for Gordon.

So they played disgracefully poor...but their GK was on top form...and they won

theflyingfrenchman wrote:

BilalShah wrote:Why Boumsoung starts for France?
And Scottish ratings too.

Everyone 3, except an 8 for Gordon.

BilalShah wrote:Why Boumsoung starts for France?
And Scottish ratings too.

He starts because Gallas was injuried. He played well even if he haa nothing really to do.

Well, I would say 5 for all scottish because I don't know the players. They were better in 2nd half, but they don't play on the same level than France.

The forward should have had a red for each one of his 2 big faults.

Ballack wrote:

theflyingfrenchman wrote:

BilalShah wrote:Why Boumsoung starts for France?
And Scottish ratings too.

Everyone 3, except an 8 for Gordon.

No really. Georgia were twice as good as Scotland.

theflyingfrenchman wrote:Coupet - 6- Nopthing to do, can't do anything about the goal
Abidal - 8 - Kept the Scottish forward man in check.
Boumsong - 7 - Dominated McFadden, but where is he on the corner.
Thuram- 8- Solid
Sagnol- 7- Had nothing to do, but didn't get up enough.
Ribery - 2 - Utter rubbish
Makélélé - 8 - excellent again
Vieira - 8 - One goal unjustly ruled out for offside
Malouda - 7 - Got forward well, had one very good shot saved
Henry - 9 - DId everything but score
Trez - 5 - Got one chance which was debatedly ruled out for offside. Otherwise very quiet.

You lose to Scotland and everyone gets 7,8 and 9.

Parks Lives wrote:

theflyingfrenchman wrote:Coupet - 6- Nopthing to do, can't do anything about the goal
Abidal - 8 - Kept the Scottish forward man in check.
Boumsong - 7 - Dominated McFadden, but where is he on the corner.
Thuram- 8- Solid
Sagnol- 7- Had nothing to do, but didn't get up enough.
Ribery - 2 - Utter rubbish
Makélélé - 8 - excellent again
Vieira - 8 - One goal unjustly ruled out for offside
Malouda - 7 - Got forward well, had one very good shot saved
Henry - 9 - DId everything but score
Trez - 5 - Got one chance which was debatedly ruled out for offside. Otherwise very quiet.

You lose to Scotland and everyone gets 7,8 and 9.

Did you see the game? No.

Napoléon wrote:

BilalShah wrote:Why Boumsoung starts for France?
And Scottish ratings too.

He starts because Gallas was injuried. He played well even if he haa nothing really to do.

Well, I would say 5 for all scottish because I don't know the players. They were better in 2nd half, but they don't play on the same level than France.

The forward should have had a red for each one of his 2 big faults.

Obviously they don't play on the same level as France. France have more quality.

But their win was epic. Well done to them.

Parks Lives wrote:

theflyingfrenchman wrote:Coupet - 6- Nopthing to do, can't do anything about the goal
Abidal - 8 - Kept the Scottish forward man in check.
Boumsong - 7 - Dominated McFadden, but where is he on the corner.
Thuram- 8- Solid
Sagnol- 7- Had nothing to do, but didn't get up enough.
Ribery - 2 - Utter rubbish
Makélélé - 8 - excellent again
Vieira - 8 - One goal unjustly ruled out for offside
Malouda - 7 - Got forward well, had one very good shot saved
Henry - 9 - DId everything but score
Trez - 5 - Got one chance which was debatedly ruled out for offside. Otherwise very quiet.

You lose to Scotland and everyone gets 7,8 and 9.

Yes, he is exaggerating a few. But we are not bad loser. We played badly, but we were highly robbed tonight. Referee was very good. He dissallowed rightly the two french goals, but should have sent off the scottish forward.

Forza Italia!Forza Milan! wrote:

Napoléon wrote:

BilalShah wrote:Why Boumsoung starts for France?
And Scottish ratings too.

He starts because Gallas was injuried. He played well even if he haa nothing really to do.

Well, I would say 5 for all scottish because I don't know the players. They were better in 2nd half, but they don't play on the same level than France.

The forward should have had a red for each one of his 2 big faults.

Obviously they don't play on the same level as France. France have more quality.

But their win was epic. Well done to them.

Yes, an historic victory for scottish football. Well done.

Napoléon wrote:

Parks Lives wrote:

theflyingfrenchman wrote:Coupet - 6- Nopthing to do, can't do anything about the goal
Abidal - 8 - Kept the Scottish forward man in check.
Boumsong - 7 - Dominated McFadden, but where is he on the corner.
Thuram- 8- Solid
Sagnol- 7- Had nothing to do, but didn't get up enough.
Ribery - 2 - Utter rubbish
Makélélé - 8 - excellent again
Vieira - 8 - One goal unjustly ruled out for offside
Malouda - 7 - Got forward well, had one very good shot saved
Henry - 9 - DId everything but score
Trez - 5 - Got one chance which was debatedly ruled out for offside. Otherwise very quiet.

You lose to Scotland and everyone gets 7,8 and 9.

Yes, he is exaggerating a few. But we are not bad loser. We played badly, but we were highly robbed tonight. Referee was very good. He dissallowed rightly the two french goals, but should have sent off the scottish forward.

Don't agree. Trezeguet's goal came off a Scottish defender and Vieira wasn't offside for his goal.

We only had 70% possession. Felt like more.

Wish I got to see this game.

Parks Lives wrote:Fletcher > Vieira.

Well said.

theflyingfrenchman wrote:We only had 70% possession. Felt like more.

How did Ribery play flyingfrench?

yours truly wrote:

theflyingfrenchman wrote:We only had 70% possession. Felt like more.

How did Ribery play flyingfrench?

He gave him 2 out of 10 a few pages back

Brian3-5-2 wrote:Wish I got to see this game.

saw bits of the first half (total and utter french dominance) and the last half hour (scotland just hanging on)... atmosphere was amazing... france didnt deserve to lose. one of those games where scotland couldnt get near the ball... one team has dozens of chances but then the other grabs a goal from the only way they can possibly score (a set piece) and scotland hung on brilliantly

COTR wrote:

Brian3-5-2 wrote:Wish I got to see this game.

saw bits of the first half (total and utter french dominance) and the last half hour (scotland just hanging on)... atmosphere was amazing... france didnt deserve. one of those games where scotland couldnt get near the ball... one team has dozens of chances but then the other grabs a goal from the only way they can possibly score (a set piece) and scotland hung on brilliantly

Sonds kind of like T.T - Sweden

MexicanTeamOfTheRosesFan wrote:

COTR wrote:

Brian3-5-2 wrote:Wish I got to see this game.

saw bits of the first half (total and utter french dominance) and the last half hour (scotland just hanging on)... atmosphere was amazing... france didnt deserve. one of those games where scotland couldnt get near the ball... one team has dozens of chances but then the other grabs a goal from the only way they can possibly score (a set piece) and scotland hung on brilliantly

Sonds kind of like T.T - Sweden

France are my favourite team but on that basis Scotland deserved to win. If you don't take your chances at International level it's going to happen. Weird though the match panned out totally how I thought it wouldn't.

theflyingfrenchman wrote:
Don't agree. Trezeguet's goal came off a Scottish defender and Vieira wasn't offside for his goal.

clutching at straws mate. both definately offside. France only had one proper oportunity(Henry header) I was pretty sure we would hold on(which is rare when watching Scotland) France didn't really show much to be honest.

Apparently we haven't lost a Euro qualifier at Hampden since 1987! Vienna here we come!

That header by Henry was shocking. It was like a pass back.

More evidence for the Henry small pitch theory.

Johnny_thunde_R wrote:

theflyingfrenchman wrote:
Don't agree. Trezeguet's goal came off a Scottish defender and Vieira wasn't offside for his goal.

clutching at straws mate. both definately offside. France only had one proper oportunity(Henry header) I was pretty sure we would hold on(which is rare when watching Scotland) France didn't really show much to be honest.

Apparently we haven't lost a Euro qualifier at Hampden since 1987! Vienna here we come!

Trez's shot came from a pass by a Scottish defender. Logically, he then isn't offside no? That's why they created passive offside.

The main problem was that Trez and Ribery were shit. Had we played Saha and Govou we'd probably have won. Still pissed off.