by bluenine Sat Apr 07, 2007 1:15 am
merseyman wrote:
You've just given a perfect example of what I was saying above. You'll be hard-pushed to find an Englishman in here who doesn't think that the ManU fans were probably partially to blame
"Probably partially to blame" - thats exactly where I disagree with you and some other english fans here. I think they were
as MUCH to blame as the Roma fans.
merseyman wrote:
(although your essay in favour of Italian policing yesterday leads me to think you grew up in mid-seventies Chile... enough to make anyone's skin crawl).
Obviously Merseyman, you don't know much about riot police and mob control. I can understand that, most people don't. While I did not grow up in mid-70s chile or anything like that, I did grow up in a family of policemen including my father, and I do understand some basics of how it works. Let me try and explain this in short. The main objective of riot police is to prevent the worst case scenario. The most efficient way to do this is to react as soon as the crowd trouble starts. The idea behind a "lathi-charge" (baton) is not to punish all the guilty as some people here imagine (thats NOT the main job of riot police) but to set an example which will serve as a strong deterrant. This is not just restricted to India or mid-70s chile if you prefer, but riot police all over the world. You will see in all such cases that the riot police will hit at the trouble-makers CLOSEST to them, and hit them bad. The idea is to break the mob, and ensure that the others change their mind after they see how badly some were hit. Its NOT about being fair and doing justice. When a mob is going out of hand, you don't have time to be fair or do justice, there are more important things that need doing - like preventing a large scale riot.
Do I think this is civil?? No, but there is nothing civil about a mob either - things can very quickly go completely out of hand, remember heysel??
Do I think that the riot police would have done the same thing if it were Inter fans instead of ManU fans?? Yes, I am pretty sure they would have reacted the same way, even tho most media here seems to think very differently.
Do I think there is place for riot police inside football stadiums?? Actually no, but unfortunately thats the law in Italy.
I think the ManU fans who rushed to the barrier made my skin crawl more than the policemen who hit them. I don't know if you have ever seen an out of control mob in your life, merseyman, I have.