by Torrente Mon Aug 06, 2007 8:49 am
Jaime wrote: Torrente wrote:Now it's time for Schuster to decide which players should stay or go. Assuming we get Robben and Ballack, I honestly think every canterano besides Soldado and Torres should be loaned out. None of them have convinced me in the slightest.
After today, Balboa has given me a few doubts about selling him, but he should be loaned out at least. I still doubt that he'll ever be good enough to play in the first team, but maybe he deserves a chance.
Bueno, Adrian, and Granero don't look ready to me and their options to play with be severely limited anyway, so they should be loaned out as well.
De la Red has been a big disappointment. He was absolute $h!t today and didn't do much more in other games. It doesn't seem like he's ready for the first team either. I think the mistake has been not to have loaned him out 1 or 2 years ago, so he's actually stagnated instead of improving.
Salgado should be shown the door and given away for free if necessary. He's completely useless and Cicinho is a much better backup.
Baptista's stay in a toss-up. I don't think Schuster really trusts him so if an offer higher than 15 million Euros come, I think we should sell him. I wouldn't mind if he stays though. He seems determined to fight for a place in the team and I respect that.
I agree with everything you say except for I am in favor of dumping Cicinho as well. The problem with a lot of the canteranos showing themselves to still be green is that the squad is going to be very small. Particularly on the wings we would only have Robben (assuming we get him) and Robinho.
I admit Cicinho has been bad in this pre-season as well, but without him and Salgado we would have no backup for Ramos. To have Cicinho as backup RB is a luxury few teams could have.
But although the squad would be thin without those canteranos, we would still have decent backups in most areas of the field.
CBs - Pepe, Cannavaro, Metzelder, Ramos
Fullbacks - Ramos, Torres, Marcelo, Cicinho (and Pepe can play as a fullback in an emergency)
DMs - Gago, Diarra, (hopefully Emerson will be sold)
AMs - Guti, Ballack
Wingers - Robinho, Robben, Higuain, Marcelo (the latter 2 not real wingers but can play there)
Forwards - Ruud, Soldado, Saviola, Raul, Robinho
So our real problem is in the wings, which is why Balboa will probably stay. Since we could use other center midfielders, I think De la Red will stay as well.