Would you like to react to this message? Create an account in a few clicks or log in to continue.

+38
Sgoater1
Sir Les
Rez
fcb
Cesc Soler
Pierre Littbarski
Hlebagone
Z
DS
110%
StevieG
Sheffield gunner
L.r.d
DD
Rosy
Fey
The Pröfessör
debaser
Chocolate Thunder
Luis
Isco Benny
Ä
Puro
Roger Hunt
Football Genius
SuperMario
Machiavel
lrdsucksgoats
tigerthesmurf
Glenarch of the Glen
Parks lives
Kimbo
Nightwing
COTR
Tweesus
Dwarf
Deluded F*ck™
Batman
42 posters

    How Rafa Lost Liverpool The Title

    avatar
    Brian2468


    Number of posts : 4875
    Age : 65
    Registration date : 2006-08-06

    How Rafa Lost Liverpool The Title - Page 10 Empty Re: How Rafa Lost Liverpool The Title

    Post by Brian2468 Tue Jan 08, 2008 4:22 pm

    110% wrote:
    L r d wrote:Yes but now get some reality in your idiotic mind and realise their fighting for 4th place not 1st. <Ale>

    I think we have easier fixtures than Liverpool also, so they will do well to keep the gap to 10 points Biggrin <Ale>

    seems like you caught spanky's disease off him,
    they're = they are

    can't discuss anything without insults? I do not realise the points were already decided, why do we even bother to play then? since you've got easier fixtures how about we just give you 12 points for the next 5 games and liverpool 10. Are arsenal's fixtures easier? if so maybe we can give them 14 points. What about chelsea? No need to play we can just decide on paper, I'm guessing by the end of the season arsenal are the winners. Well done arsenal, when's the victory parade?

    Is your brain able to understand that what has happened in past seasons is an indicator but that the future is not yet decided? that liverpool have much less chance of winning the league but still have one, that you still have to play all the games even if they look easier, while playing in the CL, you can get injuries, tiredness (your excuse right there for losing to Milan last year, and kaka being the best player in the world), luck etc.

    Chelsea and arsenal have a couple of players missing for the african nations, could even come back injured. Manu could get an injury to rooney or cronaldo. Liverpool could fluke a last minute set-piece at old trafford, equally liverpool could get injuries and end up 5th etc. So there is a long way to go and not one thing is decided right now. Do you remember being really far behind newcastle and winning the league? or were you fighting for second place then?

    Can your idiotic mind understand this?

    Such a rude post pirat Why would you defend Liverpool, they can not help struggling to hold down a top four position.
    L.r.d
    L.r.d


    Number of posts : 5614
    Age : 40
    Registration date : 2007-12-21

    How Rafa Lost Liverpool The Title - Page 10 Empty Re: How Rafa Lost Liverpool The Title

    Post by L.r.d Tue Jan 08, 2008 4:39 pm

    My mind has said Liverpool wouldn't come close, yours the oppisite what is happenening? did you say the same thing last year? yep so did i what happenend?

    Load of mumbo jumbo, Liverpool have never come from that far behind, it would be catching 10+ points on 2 teams not one, they have an inferior team unlike in the other scenario's they have the more difficult fixtures, and as usual you will be proven wrong and me right Ale Keep picking up on minor typos or grammar mistakes on an forum ffs, maybe the only thing you will get right Ale moron Biggrin
    Football Genius
    Football Genius


    Number of posts : 7743
    Age : 40
    Supports : Liverpool
    Registration date : 2006-08-07

    How Rafa Lost Liverpool The Title - Page 10 Empty Re: How Rafa Lost Liverpool The Title

    Post by Football Genius Tue Jan 08, 2008 5:11 pm

    Liverpool won't win the league this season, of that i am sure. But it doesn't mean we should aim to win every game we play untill the end of the season, if we finish within touching distance 0-10 points from the top team, we at least will have enough motivation to throw at the players in the Summer, along with of course some new faces.

    I still think we've overachieved in recent seasons in the league and are underachieving this season when you consider our potential first team its not that far off Arsenal's, Chelseas and Uniteds and arguably better in some departments than some of our closest rivals ok
    avatar
    110%


    Number of posts : 8978
    Age : 50
    Registration date : 2006-08-07

    How Rafa Lost Liverpool The Title - Page 10 Empty Re: How Rafa Lost Liverpool The Title

    Post by 110% Wed Jan 09, 2008 9:20 am

    L r d wrote:My mind has said Liverpool wouldn't come close, yours the oppisite what is happenening? did you say the same thing last year? yep so did i what happenend?

    Load of mumbo jumbo, Liverpool have never come from that far behind, it would be catching 10+ points on 2 teams not one, they have an inferior team unlike in the other scenario's they have the more difficult fixtures, and as usual you will be proven wrong and me right Ale Keep picking up on minor typos or grammar mistakes on an forum ffs, maybe the only thing you will get right Ale moron Biggrin

    you're getting better at least, some reasoning in this post, they also have chelsea although they are not 10 points in front.

    I pointed out the spelling mistake just because it's comical that some guy calls another one idiot and moron but cannot tell the difference between "they're" and "their", especially when you're english and I'm not (I'll be one of those foreigners you'll be complaining about taking your job if I ever come to england for being better educated than you and speaking your own language better Wink, that's if you actually have a job).

    I'm afraid I pointed out far more than grammar mistakes, just becasue you cannot understand when things are pointed out to you such as it not only being about easier fixtures and you having the "best" players in the world such as cronaldo, anderson (1 and 2 weren't they in recent awards, and motm in every match they play Wink) etc that injuries, luck, fixture congestion with the CL etc come into it. And that's the beauty of football, you really don't know what can happen.

    Anyway if liverpool don't win the league this season I won't be wrong as I haven't said they will above, what I was pointing out to luis was not to be too depressed because it is not actually a fact that teams 13 points behind don't win the league it just hasn't happened yet (the same as the bottom at xmas was only true until west brom showed it wasn't) Doh

    I would like as many teams as possible competing at the top until the end of the season to keep it interesting, I don't want manu and arsenal having a 2 horse race again, as it's boring. The best thing to happen next would be for both manu and arsenal to lose a couple of games so that cheslea, liverpool and man city can catch up.
    Allez les rouges
    Allez les rouges


    Number of posts : 8098
    Age : 108
    Supports : Deutschland, Arsenal
    Favourite Player : Jens Lehmann
    Registration date : 2006-08-07

    How Rafa Lost Liverpool The Title - Page 10 Empty Re: How Rafa Lost Liverpool The Title

    Post by Allez les rouges Wed Jan 09, 2008 10:33 am

    I don't really want to get involved in this, though it seems to me that one should have a firmer grasp of punctuation and what, for instance, a comma is for before ridiculing another's (lack of) literacy. Besides, this "I'm not English" schtick without stating your own loyalties, even when you often object to all sorts of criticism of England or, say, Liverpool, is a bit perplexing...

    The fact remains that the original post was startlingly rude and patronising, and a little puzzling: as much as I'd like Liverpool of all the other "big" teams to still be in the title hunt, it's reasonable for many to have concluded that they've lost so much ground now that the title is a near-impossibility. There's no need to insult this view, even if it's provocatively phrased, as in the title of this thread – as if everyone is stupid for thinking that Liverpool have blown it, while you alone are enlightened for saying "anything can happen and it isn't over yet", scarcely a profound observation itself.

    It's true that the media have a tendency to react hastily with their judgements and predictions, as with the perception that United were overwhelming favourites for the title once Arsenal "only" drew at Portsmouth; predictably, once United lost and Arsenal won next time around, things no longer seemed quite so straightforward. But it's reasonable to discuss Benítez's approach and tactics in the light of the way Liverpool have undeniably stagnated in the league (although I for one still think he's a top, top manager), and this thread has seen some very decent debate on the matter.

    There's no need to ridicule the fact that people see fit to question Benítez after the club's recent investments and Liverpool's recent indifferent performances in the Premier League: it's pretty obvious to most people.
    Ä
    Ä


    Number of posts : 11028
    Age : 94
    Registration date : 2006-09-04

    How Rafa Lost Liverpool The Title - Page 10 Empty Re: How Rafa Lost Liverpool The Title

    Post by Ä Wed Jan 09, 2008 10:39 am

    you sound like a lawyer, allez

    alternatively

    like a thorough German

    well done, old chap

    you are getting there

    and now, please, let us have your footnotes and bibliography

    Whistle
    Nightwing
    Nightwing


    Number of posts : 4563
    Age : 50
    Supports : Manchester United FC
    Favourite Player : The Red Wiz (C.Ronaldo)
    Registration date : 2006-08-07

    How Rafa Lost Liverpool The Title - Page 10 Empty Re: How Rafa Lost Liverpool The Title

    Post by Nightwing Wed Jan 09, 2008 1:34 pm

    Luis wrote:Can I just point out that Rafa didn't 'lose us the league title' as the thread suggests. We never had the league title and we certainly had no divine right to win it this year. Rafa alone isn't to blame for putting us out the title race for this season. It was a joint effort from his decisions on a few occasions, the wanker owners who know nothing about football, transfers etc and come to England for 2 games a season (some passion that) and finally the following players: Riise, Kewell, Pennant, Alonso, Kuyt, Sissoko, Voronin and even Crouch on a few occasions.

    What an utter load of tosh!!!

    Hoe does the owners turning up or not make any f'cking diff? Roman truns up a lot - they didnt win it last year! Glazer Sr has as far as i know never even been to OT - and we won it last year!

    Face it chidl - the only reason y'er team are NOT cmpeting for it seriously is cos ther NOT GOOD ENOUGH!
    End of.

    Close this thread - matter has been resolved by me.

    Thank ee'. ok
    L.r.d
    L.r.d


    Number of posts : 5614
    Age : 40
    Registration date : 2007-12-21

    How Rafa Lost Liverpool The Title - Page 10 Empty Re: How Rafa Lost Liverpool The Title

    Post by L.r.d Wed Jan 09, 2008 1:37 pm

    Cleared up a 14 page argument in 7 lines, it's why he's the head of the redbloods Devil Biggrin <Ale>
    Roger Hunt
    Roger Hunt


    Number of posts : 10115
    Age : 54
    Registration date : 2006-08-07

    How Rafa Lost Liverpool The Title - Page 10 Empty Re: How Rafa Lost Liverpool The Title

    Post by Roger Hunt Wed Jan 09, 2008 2:05 pm

    L r d wrote:Spouted a load of ill-thought-out cliche, it's why he's the head of the redbloods Devil Biggrin <Ale>

    ok
    avatar
    110%


    Number of posts : 8978
    Age : 50
    Registration date : 2006-08-07

    How Rafa Lost Liverpool The Title - Page 10 Empty Re: How Rafa Lost Liverpool The Title

    Post by 110% Wed Jan 09, 2008 2:14 pm

    Allez les rouges wrote:I don't really want to get involved in this, though it seems to me that one should have a firmer grasp of punctuation and what, for instance, a comma is for before ridiculing another's (lack of) literacy. Besides, this "I'm not English" schtick without stating your own loyalties, even when you often object to all sorts of criticism of England or, say, Liverpool, is a bit perplexing...

    The fact remains that the original post was startlingly rude and patronising, and a little puzzling: as much as I'd like Liverpool of all the other "big" teams to still be in the title hunt, it's reasonable for many to have concluded that they've lost so much ground now that the title is a near-impossibility. There's no need to insult this view, even if it's provocatively phrased, as in the title of this thread – as if everyone is stupid for thinking that Liverpool have blown it, while you alone are enlightened for saying "anything can happen and it isn't over yet", scarcely a profound observation itself.

    It's true that the media have a tendency to react hastily with their judgements and predictions, as with the perception that United were overwhelming favourites for the title once Arsenal "only" drew at Portsmouth; predictably, once United lost and Arsenal won next time around, things no longer seemed quite so straightforward. But it's reasonable to discuss Benítez's approach and tactics in the light of the way Liverpool have undeniably stagnated in the league (although I for one still think he's a top, top manager), and this thread has seen some very decent debate on the matter.

    There's no need to ridicule the fact that people see fit to question Benítez after the club's recent investments and Liverpool's recent indifferent performances in the Premier League: it's pretty obvious to most people.

    I didn't read all 7 pages after being away, and I more replied to the title and the last couple of pages than anyhting else and but I don't see how this is rude to any poster, or ridiculing anyone, more telling luis not to be so depressed:

    110% wrote:sorry I was away over xmas so I didn't realise someone had won the league. I was pretty shocked, but I cannot find any information on the internet about it, which I find very disturbing!! So who won??

    Also I have seen that luis seems to be very depressed these days. So for him I would say that he should remember that a team at the bottom at xmas always gets relegated, except of course when they don't (like west brom). And a team 13 points back at xmas doesn't win the league except of course when they do.

    That is the beauty of football.

    I don't particularly care one way or the other about benitez either, and although as you say people are aware anything can happen in football, people are aware of most things (eg how Cr@p england are, doesn't stop someone writing it down over and over does it Wink).

    as for the use of they're and their, lrd was the one callling me a moron etc (there's the insulting part), so I'm sorry if I find someone who can't grasp this simple concept yet calls other people stupid quite humuorous and tak the piss

    and I have explained my "loyalties" or lack thereof of several times already, but can do again if it helps you in any way. Born in hong kong, mixture of nationalities none of them english, but lived in england from 1992-2001 more or less, lived in italy since then. A fan of amongst others ronaldo (the real one), and from the EPL henry and gerrard. Doesn't make me a fan of england, although I did live in england for 9 years and am probably more familiar with theirs and italy's players than others, and doesn't make me a fan of either arsenal (or now barcelona because of henry) or liverpool either (never been there).

    i think that answer's all of your points, so pelase tell me where i used the comma incorrectly
    avatar
    110%


    Number of posts : 8978
    Age : 50
    Registration date : 2006-08-07

    How Rafa Lost Liverpool The Title - Page 10 Empty Re: How Rafa Lost Liverpool The Title

    Post by 110% Wed Jan 09, 2008 2:20 pm

    i should have said I haven't read all 13 pages, but I've just gone back to the first page, and it wasn't exactly stimulating reading, more of the usual puro bull, spanky's "liverpool are crap" etc.
    Allez les rouges
    Allez les rouges


    Number of posts : 8098
    Age : 108
    Supports : Deutschland, Arsenal
    Favourite Player : Jens Lehmann
    Registration date : 2006-08-07

    How Rafa Lost Liverpool The Title - Page 10 Empty Re: How Rafa Lost Liverpool The Title

    Post by Allez les rouges Wed Jan 09, 2008 3:29 pm

    110% wrote:
    L r d wrote:My mind has said Liverpool wouldn't come close, yours the oppisite what is happenening? did you say the same thing last year? yep so did i what happenend?

    Load of mumbo jumbo, Liverpool have never come from that far behind, it would be catching 10+ points on 2 teams not one, they have an inferior team unlike in the other scenario's they have the more difficult fixtures, and as usual you will be proven wrong and me right Ale Keep picking up on minor typos or grammar mistakes on an forum ffs, maybe the only thing you will get right Ale moron Biggrin

    You're getting better at least, some reasoning in this post. They also have Chelsea, although they are not 10 points in front.

    I pointed out the spelling mistake just because it's comical that some guy calls another one idiot and moron but cannot tell the difference between "they're" and "their", especially when you're English and I'm not (I'll be one of those foreigners you'll be complaining about taking your job if I ever come to England for being better educated than you and speaking your own language better Wink, that's if you actually have a job).

    I'm afraid I pointed out far more than grammar mistakes, just because you cannot understand when things are pointed out to you such as it not only being about easier fixtures and you having the "best" players in the world such as cronaldo, anderson (1 and 2 weren't they in recent awards, and motm in every match they play Wink) etc, that injuries, luck, fixture congestion with the CL, etc, come into it. And that's the beauty of football you really don't know what can happen.

    Anyway if liverpool don't win the league this season, I won't be wrong, as I haven't said they will above. What I was pointing out to luis was not to be too depressed, because it is not actually a fact that teams 13 points behind don't win the league; it just hasn't happened yet (the same as the bottom at xmas was only true until west brom showed it wasn't) Doh

    I would like as many teams as possible competing at the top until the end of the season to keep it interesting. I don't want manu and arsenal having a 2-horse race again, as it's boring. The best thing to happen next would be for both manu and arsenal to lose a couple of games so that chelsea, liverpool and man city can catch up.

    Just how you might adjust/repunctuate the post of yours that I was thinking of if you wanted to take the high ground – since you asked, no offence of course. (Fair enough if you don't want to capitalize – I stopped bothering with those...)

    Still think it was reasonable for people to see Liverpool as out of the title race at this stage.

    Fascinating stuff to hear – so did you grow up in Hong Kong? Or which cut is the deepest, as it were?
    avatar
    110%


    Number of posts : 8978
    Age : 50
    Registration date : 2006-08-07

    How Rafa Lost Liverpool The Title - Page 10 Empty Re: How Rafa Lost Liverpool The Title

    Post by 110% Thu Jan 10, 2008 11:30 am

    As I said I was only taking the piss because lrd called me stupid and then can't tell the difference between they're and their. Also he has a thing about foreigners in England taking their jobs (part of another thread), and actually just goes around insulting me. I pointed out to him the foreigners are doing the the jobs that the English are too lazy, or not qualified to do (so that was that part of the post).

    I have seen spanky using the same they're and their thing and never pointed it out, and don't normally point out that kind of stuff. Also if I'm writing a lot quickly, and I'm at work, so I don't normally waste my time with punctuation on this board.

    anyway back to punctuationless writing:
    grew up in hong kong, actually playing rugby until i was 16 then changed over to football because the rugby was too violent. Was not really interested in football on tv and only really watched stuff like the world cup (hence a fan of ronaldo). Realised that watching football was part of english life when I went to university there in 1992, so started watching it then, but serie A was far superior. The manu team back then was organised and very well balanced with a small number of exceptional players, and played a mixture of nice and ugly football like chelsea now so I find some of the comments, from the likes of lrd and spanky, about that team having the best players in the world, playing the best football etc to be quite deisleresque. I am really against overrating (players, teams etc.) until they have proved it.

    As for liverpool being out of the title they very likely are, and maybe chelsea as well (losing their african players and stuff) and maybe man city were never in it. But I saw inter lose serie a a few years ago on the last day of the season, with either juve or roma being able to win it. That was the most interesting serie A I ever saw. Every week we would get together to try and watch all the games when we werent going to the san siro. The inter team now is so dominant it is boring, and I found that about juve before as well. I didn't mind chelsea winning a couple of years ago jsut because it was someone different and able to compete, and I would like to see liverpool and now man city at least compete so it is interesting for the neutral. I can see arsenal losing a few matches due to the african nations cup and injuries. So the favourites for me are manu, but if they lose a couple of matches, and concentrate on the CL, I can see chelsea and liverpool get back in (assuming of course that they have good runs of wins, but harder for chelsea with their african players). So for me it all depends really on 1 team losing a few matches (not 3 teams) and that's manu. I can definitely see liverpool closing the gap especially if they go out of the CL and manu, arsenal and chelsea stay in. The only reason why I don't think man city will be up there is that I don't think they can have a run like 10 wins in a row, which I think liverpool and chelsea are capable of. Hopefully though they will be next year.
    Roger Hunt
    Roger Hunt


    Number of posts : 10115
    Age : 54
    Registration date : 2006-08-07

    How Rafa Lost Liverpool The Title - Page 10 Empty Re: How Rafa Lost Liverpool The Title

    Post by Roger Hunt Thu Jan 10, 2008 11:33 am

    Next year will be the real crunch point - isn't that when the CL places drop to 3?
    avatar
    110%


    Number of posts : 8978
    Age : 50
    Registration date : 2006-08-07

    How Rafa Lost Liverpool The Title - Page 10 Empty Re: How Rafa Lost Liverpool The Title

    Post by 110% Thu Jan 10, 2008 11:37 am

    as for why liverpool are in the position they are in, I blame mostly the players more than benitez, especially the strikers and attacking players. I've seen them miss so many chances and they are way too reliant on torres and gerrard. As soon as one of them has a bad game they don't win.
    Roger Hunt
    Roger Hunt


    Number of posts : 10115
    Age : 54
    Registration date : 2006-08-07

    How Rafa Lost Liverpool The Title - Page 10 Empty Re: How Rafa Lost Liverpool The Title

    Post by Roger Hunt Thu Jan 10, 2008 11:40 am

    The counter-argument is that Benitez bought most of them and it's his job to motivate them - which is pretty reasonable imo.

    He needs to replace Pako.
    avatar
    110%


    Number of posts : 8978
    Age : 50
    Registration date : 2006-08-07

    How Rafa Lost Liverpool The Title - Page 10 Empty Re: How Rafa Lost Liverpool The Title

    Post by 110% Thu Jan 10, 2008 2:16 pm

    Roger Hunt wrote:The counter-argument is that Benitez bought most of them and it's his job to motivate them - which is pretty reasonable imo.

    He needs to replace Pako.

    you're a liverpool fan and a sensible one, and of course the management also has its faults, but you are restricted on how much you can motivate someone. A 7M pound player like pennant is not going to play like a 15M pound player, he plays at his level. And that has a lot to do with the budget, you would never buy pennant, bellamy etc unless there were budget resrictions. If you buy a player at around 7M that's what you get, even with motivation and possibly being on top form for a few weeks, he's normally going to play at a certain level, if you buy a player at 15M then you have a totally different level of player to start with, a potential match winner and maybe he can be sold again. To me it's a total shock that he made a profit on bellamy, and I can only put that down inflation due to clubs getting more money from tv (and I mean no offence to deano in case he comes after me Wink).

    as for formation, motivation etc, yes they've had some bad games but no more than manu, arsenal, chelsea, the difference is that they drew whereas the others still won theirs, and that comes back to the potential match winners when the team plays badly, they only have 2. Babel could potentially be one (and notice the price tag), pennant will not be one, and benayoun has his moments. I know that they've spent a lot of money for rebuilding the whole squad, but right now he needs to spend big on 1 or 2 attacking players, who are going to get you 3 points when you play badly, because you will.

    i remember the discussion about 5 in the middle being defensive e.g. against wigan, and if liverpool had actually put away the chances they had in that game, there wouldn't even be a discussion. The missed chances (and good goalkeeping) result in a draw and then people analysing it afterwards notice that the formation had 5 in the middle. Stats are not the be-all and end-all of course but as a reference:
    Shots (on Goal) Liverpool 16(11) Wigan 7(1)
    Saves Liverpool 1 Wigan 11

    For me they created enough chances to win that game, just never took them. I don't believe benitez's formation of 5 in midfield was the reason for the draw, or particularly defensive, more like bad finishing and great goalkeeping.
    Roger Hunt
    Roger Hunt


    Number of posts : 10115
    Age : 54
    Registration date : 2006-08-07

    How Rafa Lost Liverpool The Title - Page 10 Empty Re: How Rafa Lost Liverpool The Title

    Post by Roger Hunt Thu Jan 10, 2008 2:39 pm

    It's certainly the case that restricted funds have prevented Rafa buying the players he wanted - the two most obvious examples I can think of are Vidic and Malouda.

    Your point about Babel is well-made too. He is a young developing player. To spend £12m on a player like that is a risk but can pay off; however he's highly unlikely to make a big impact in his first season.

    I'm not so surprised about Bellamy - I thought that we got him pretty cheaply and strikers go for more money than other players.

    I also think you're right about the Wigan result - but that is only one game.

    But I do think that Rafa cannot escape some blame for the inconsistency we've demonstrated in our performances. Rotate the players - fine; change formations - fine. But if you do both you run the risk of the players being confused as to their roles and not performing to their best.
    lrdsucksgoats
    lrdsucksgoats


    Number of posts : 9523
    Age : 82
    Supports : Decentralisation of the state
    Favourite Player : The lesser spotted Ronaldo
    Registration date : 2007-02-25

    How Rafa Lost Liverpool The Title - Page 10 Empty Re: How Rafa Lost Liverpool The Title

    Post by lrdsucksgoats Thu Jan 10, 2008 3:15 pm

    Roger Hunt wrote:
    But I do think that Rafa cannot escape some blame for the inconsistency we've demonstrated in our performances. Rotate the players - fine; change formations - fine. But if you do both you run the risk of the players being confused as to their roles and not performing to their best.

    Or even if the players aren't confused as to their own roles - it gives them no time to form proper partnerships on the field so the overall tactical plan will just be the sum of its parts.
    avatar
    110%


    Number of posts : 8978
    Age : 50
    Registration date : 2006-08-07

    How Rafa Lost Liverpool The Title - Page 10 Empty Re: How Rafa Lost Liverpool The Title

    Post by 110% Thu Jan 10, 2008 3:42 pm

    Anas Al-Liby wrote:
    Roger Hunt wrote:
    But I do think that Rafa cannot escape some blame for the inconsistency we've demonstrated in our performances. Rotate the players - fine; change formations - fine. But if you do both you run the risk of the players being confused as to their roles and not performing to their best.

    Or even if the players aren't confused as to their own roles - it gives them no time to form proper partnerships on the field so the overall tactical plan will just be the sum of its parts.

    I agree with all of this, just not with the view that it is all down to benitez, of course he also shares some blame, but the players do train all week on their formations, and benitez obviously thinks it works, then some of them can't get it right in the match. While we might blame benitez for the formation, I'd expect professional footballers who do nothing except play football to be able to play different formations, tactics, positions etc.

    although i agree that they need to play together more to develop partnerships, partnerships don't only develop within matches either, these guys do train together all week
    Sir Les
    Sir Les


    Number of posts : 1451
    Supports : Arsenal
    Registration date : 2007-09-10

    How Rafa Lost Liverpool The Title - Page 10 Empty Re: How Rafa Lost Liverpool The Title

    Post by Sir Les Thu Jan 10, 2008 11:26 pm

    Roger Hunt wrote:It's certainly the case that restricted funds have prevented Rafa buying the players he wanted - the two most obvious examples I can think of are Vidic and Malouda.

    Your point about Babel is well-made too. He is a young developing player. To spend £12m on a player like that is a risk but can pay off; however he's highly unlikely to make a big impact in his first season.

    I'm not so surprised about Bellamy - I thought that we got him pretty cheaply and strikers go for more money than other players.

    I also think you're right about the Wigan result - but that is only one game.

    But I do think that Rafa cannot escape some blame for the inconsistency we've demonstrated in our performances. Rotate the players - fine; change formations - fine. But if you do both you run the risk of the players being confused as to their roles and not performing to their best.

    See how far you'd get with Arsenal's 'restricted funds'. This really is a very weak argument from Liverpool supporters.
    avatar
    110%


    Number of posts : 8978
    Age : 50
    Registration date : 2006-08-07

    How Rafa Lost Liverpool The Title - Page 10 Empty Re: How Rafa Lost Liverpool The Title

    Post by 110% Fri Jan 11, 2008 9:35 am

    you mean like chelsea? previously blackburn? the money that manu have been spending for the last 15 years, and now the money that man city have, that somehow they end up challenging?

    how about inter, juve, milan in serie a? or barcelona, real etc? or bayern in bundesliga? lyon in france? All the biggest spenders in their own leagues, and the most successful clubs.

    arsenal is the exception to making it with "restricted funds" (by their own league standards), and that is probably down to wenger's scouting network and spotting talent before their price rockets. Can you name another team regularly doing the same? There are bound to be some who have a one-off season.

    Money is probably the most important single contribution to winning the league.
    Chocolate Thunder
    Chocolate Thunder


    Number of posts : 15804
    Age : 37
    Supports : Borussia Dortmund and Liverpool
    Registration date : 2007-01-06

    How Rafa Lost Liverpool The Title - Page 10 Empty Re: How Rafa Lost Liverpool The Title

    Post by Chocolate Thunder Fri Jan 11, 2008 9:36 am

    King Otto wrote:
    Roger Hunt wrote:It's certainly the case that restricted funds have prevented Rafa buying the players he wanted - the two most obvious examples I can think of are Vidic and Malouda.

    Your point about Babel is well-made too. He is a young developing player. To spend £12m on a player like that is a risk but can pay off; however he's highly unlikely to make a big impact in his first season.

    I'm not so surprised about Bellamy - I thought that we got him pretty cheaply and strikers go for more money than other players.

    I also think you're right about the Wigan result - but that is only one game.

    But I do think that Rafa cannot escape some blame for the inconsistency we've demonstrated in our performances. Rotate the players - fine; change formations - fine. But if you do both you run the risk of the players being confused as to their roles and not performing to their best.

    See how far you'd get with Arsenal's 'restricted funds'. This really is a very weak argument from Liverpool supporters.

    Its a rather weak counter argument scratch

    But we don't have a youth set up like that of Aresnal, not many do but it is improving and we are doing very well in our reserves, u18s and htroughtout the academy in general. Thus we must spend. Also your manager has a strong belief in his younger players ands giving them a chance. Rafa as we have seen, even with expensive youn signings such as Babel is very cautious. Maybe this will prove to be a good thing only time will tell.

    But lets not forget it took at least a couple of years for Wenger's youth to come of age if you will. I don't remember many youths being brought in during his first few years at Aresnal. So I'm hopeful for Rafa and for our youth at the club.


    Last edited by on Fri Jan 11, 2008 9:38 am; edited 1 time in total
    DS
    DS


    Number of posts : 12952
    Age : 39
    Supports : Manchester United , Bayern Munich
    Registration date : 2006-08-07

    How Rafa Lost Liverpool The Title - Page 10 Empty Re: How Rafa Lost Liverpool The Title

    Post by DS Fri Jan 11, 2008 9:37 am

    I you compare money spent by United from 1990 and by Liverpool it is not much of difference ,can anybody find the stats please.
    L.r.d
    L.r.d


    Number of posts : 5614
    Age : 40
    Registration date : 2007-12-21

    How Rafa Lost Liverpool The Title - Page 10 Empty Re: How Rafa Lost Liverpool The Title

    Post by L.r.d Mon Jan 14, 2008 2:04 am

    110% wrote:As I said I was only taking the piss because lrd called me stupid and then can't tell the difference between they're and their. Also he has a thing about foreigners in England taking their jobs (part of another thread), and actually just goes around insulting me. I pointed out to him the foreigners are doing the the jobs that the English are too lazy, or not qualified to do (so that was that part of the post).


    Yo dumbass you see what happenend this weekend, i guess you still think it's on!

    I can tell the difference between.....i just type quick and mistakes happen. To point them out obviously is a sign of desperation on your part. I don't have a thing about foreigners taking jobs....i have a problem with to many immigrants. They actually do jobs a dunce could do so being qualified is not an issue. Anyway back to your bullshit. Have you ever been right in your time here 110% i cant think of one fucking time. I'll even write off the incidents where you have been arguing a case or point where you didn't even see the damn game. You lie about everything and get the rest wrong. Such a pointless irrevlent individual.
    On the insults don't give what you cant take, ignorant moron.

    As i said more difficult fixtures with an inferior team means the gap will probably be increased. This week it's increased a bit already. You keep wondering why luis etc are depressed about the league table. Have a good think about that one it might come to you eventually. I expect you will be talking the same shite next year, if im here i'll call you stupid then too. and you will be miles wrong as per usual. Dumbass <Ale>
    avatar
    110%


    Number of posts : 8978
    Age : 50
    Registration date : 2006-08-07

    How Rafa Lost Liverpool The Title - Page 10 Empty Re: How Rafa Lost Liverpool The Title

    Post by 110% Mon Jan 14, 2008 2:13 pm

    L r d wrote:
    110% wrote:As I said I was only taking the piss because lrd called me stupid and then can't tell the difference between they're and their. Also he has a thing about foreigners in England taking their jobs (part of another thread), and actually just goes around insulting me. I pointed out to him the foreigners are doing the the jobs that the English are too lazy, or not qualified to do (so that was that part of the post).


    Yo dumbass you see what happenend this weekend, i guess you still think it's on!

    I can tell the difference between.....i just type quick and mistakes happen. To point them out obviously is a sign of desperation on your part. I don't have a thing about foreigners taking jobs....i have a problem with to many immigrants. They actually do jobs a dunce could do so being qualified is not an issue. Anyway back to your bullshit. Have you ever been right in your time here 110% i cant think of one fucking time. I'll even write off the incidents where you have been arguing a case or point where you didn't even see the damn game. You lie about everything and get the rest wrong. Such a pointless irrevlent individual.
    On the insults don't give what you cant take, ignorant moron.

    As i said more difficult fixtures with an inferior team means the gap will probably be increased. This week it's increased a bit already. You keep wondering why luis etc are depressed about the league table. Have a good think about that one it might come to you eventually. I expect you will be talking the same shite next year, if im here i'll call you stupid then too. and you will be miles wrong as per usual. Dumbass <Ale>

    is this irony or hypocrisy lol! lol! lol! lol! lol!

    this is probably the funniestv thing you've ever written so in reply I give yuo ...

    how about you naming cronaldo motm against against england and france during the world cup, when in fact it was hargreaves and thuram as one time (or is it 2 times Wink) when I was right and you were wrong?

    MADE UP FACTS ARE WRONG!! (unless you make something up and by some miracle it coincides with the truth)

    As for seeing the game or not that was spanky that said that as a way to discredit my opinion. It was never true then and it isn't now. It's all right though as you have demonstrated several times you have issues with the truth.

    Please continue to make up facts and call people who you cannot adequately discuss anything with a dumbass (and maybe watch some more tv programs so you can expand your vocabulary, dumbass is a bit dated now Wink)
    Sir Les
    Sir Les


    Number of posts : 1451
    Supports : Arsenal
    Registration date : 2007-09-10

    How Rafa Lost Liverpool The Title - Page 10 Empty Re: How Rafa Lost Liverpool The Title

    Post by Sir Les Mon Jan 14, 2008 6:48 pm

    Dark Savante wrote:I you compare money spent by United from 1990 and by Liverpool it is not much of difference ,can anybody find the stats please.

    They'll only be disputed if you do find them. The only thing that is certain is that over the last five years Chelsea have spent the most. There are all sorts of takes on who comes second.
    Sir Les
    Sir Les


    Number of posts : 1451
    Supports : Arsenal
    Registration date : 2007-09-10

    How Rafa Lost Liverpool The Title - Page 10 Empty Re: How Rafa Lost Liverpool The Title

    Post by Sir Les Mon Jan 14, 2008 6:52 pm

    Ade Alves wrote:
    King Otto wrote:
    Roger Hunt wrote:It's certainly the case that restricted funds have prevented Rafa buying the players he wanted - the two most obvious examples I can think of are Vidic and Malouda.

    Your point about Babel is well-made too. He is a young developing player. To spend £12m on a player like that is a risk but can pay off; however he's highly unlikely to make a big impact in his first season.

    I'm not so surprised about Bellamy - I thought that we got him pretty cheaply and strikers go for more money than other players.

    I also think you're right about the Wigan result - but that is only one game.

    But I do think that Rafa cannot escape some blame for the inconsistency we've demonstrated in our performances. Rotate the players - fine; change formations - fine. But if you do both you run the risk of the players being confused as to their roles and not performing to their best.

    See how far you'd get with Arsenal's 'restricted funds'. This really is a very weak argument from Liverpool supporters.

    Its a rather weak counter argument scratch

    But we don't have a youth set up like that of Aresnal, not many do but it is improving and we are doing very well in our reserves, u18s and htroughtout the academy in general. Thus we must spend. Also your manager has a strong belief in his younger players ands giving them a chance. Rafa as we have seen, even with expensive youn signings such as Babel is very cautious. Maybe this will prove to be a good thing only time will tell.

    But lets not forget it took at least a couple of years for Wenger's youth to come of age if you will. I don't remember many youths being brought in during his first few years at Aresnal. So I'm hopeful for Rafa and for our youth at the club.

    My point which wasn't really about Arsenal was that by the standards of most EPL teams and even European teams Liverpool's restricted funds would be shed loads to most clubs.
    L.r.d
    L.r.d


    Number of posts : 5614
    Age : 40
    Registration date : 2007-12-21

    How Rafa Lost Liverpool The Title - Page 10 Empty Re: How Rafa Lost Liverpool The Title

    Post by L.r.d Thu Jan 31, 2008 6:04 am

    110% wrote:
    L r d wrote:Yes but now get some reality in your idiotic mind and realise they're fighting for 4th place not 1st. <Ale>

    I think we have easier fixtures than Liverpool also, so they will do well to keep the gap to 10 points Biggrin <Ale>



    can't discuss anything without insults? i didn't realise that the points were already decided, why do we even bother to play then? since you've got easier fixtures how about we just give you 12 points for the next 5 games and liverpool 10. Are arsenal's fixtures easier? if so maybe we can give them 14 points. What about chelsea? No need to play we can just decide on paper, I'm guessing by the end of the season arsenal are the winners. Well done arsenal, when's the victory parade?


    <Ale>

    Sponsored content


    How Rafa Lost Liverpool The Title - Page 10 Empty Re: How Rafa Lost Liverpool The Title

    Post by Sponsored content


      Current date/time is Sat Nov 02, 2024 9:19 pm