Who's the best English PLAYER in the premier league?

We've done best central midfield player, and best english central midfield player, but who is, overall, the best English player in the league?

My top 10:

1. Steven gerrard
2. Wayne Rooney
3. Joe Cole
4. Rio Ferdinand
5. John Terry
6. Ashely Cole
7. Frank Lampard
8. Micheal Carrick
9. Micheal Owen
10. Jamie Carragher

I'm Sure people will disagree with me!

Scholes > All.

Crouching Tiger wrote:We've done best central midfield player, and best english central midfield player, but who is, overall, the best English player in the league?

My top 10:

1. Steven gerrard
2. Wayne Rooney
3. Joe Cole
4. Rio Ferdinand
5. John Terry
6. Ashely Cole
7. Frank Lampard
8. Micheal Carrick
9. Micheal Owen
10. Jamie Carragher

I'm Sure people will disagree with me!

carragher top 10

Gerrard.

Easy-peasy.

l r d wrote:

Crouching Tiger wrote:We've done best central midfield player, and best english central midfield player, but who is, overall, the best English player in the league?

My top 10:

1. Steven gerrard
2. Wayne Rooney
3. Joe Cole
4. Rio Ferdinand
5. John Terry
6. Ashely Cole
7. Frank Lampard
8. Micheal Carrick
9. Micheal Owen
10. Jamie Carragher

I'm Sure people will disagree with me!

carragher top 10

If you were to watch all our games from last season

*wait for some sort of 'I'd be very bored' remark'

You'd find that he was our best defender in the best defence in the league (imo)

Scholes > Joe Cole

Scholes > Ferdinand

Scholes > Terry

Scholes > Ashley Cole

Scholes > Lampard

Scholes > Carrick

Scholes > Owen

Scholes >>>> Carragher

Pretty much everyone bar Gerrard and Rooney.

Crouching Tiger wrote:

l r d wrote:

Crouching Tiger wrote:We've done best central midfield player, and best english central midfield player, but who is, overall, the best English player in the league?

My top 10:

1. Steven gerrard
2. Wayne Rooney
3. Joe Cole
4. Rio Ferdinand
5. John Terry
6. Ashely Cole
7. Frank Lampard
8. Micheal Carrick
9. Micheal Owen
10. Jamie Carragher

I'm Sure people will disagree with me!

carragher top 10

If you were to watch all our games from last season

*wait for some sort of 'I'd be very bored' remark'

You'd find that he was our best defender in the best defence in the league (imo)

Or you could say he is 4th choice english central defender alone, so how he makes top 10 of all english players is unknown to me.

woodgate king rio terry >> carragher and imo campbell and brown aswell.

l r d wrote:

Crouching Tiger wrote:

l r d wrote:

Crouching Tiger wrote:We've done best central midfield player, and best english central midfield player, but who is, overall, the best English player in the league?

My top 10:

1. Steven gerrard
2. Wayne Rooney
3. Joe Cole
4. Rio Ferdinand
5. John Terry
6. Ashely Cole
7. Frank Lampard
8. Micheal Carrick
9. Micheal Owen
10. Jamie Carragher

I'm Sure people will disagree with me!

carragher top 10

If you were to watch all our games from last season

*wait for some sort of 'I'd be very bored' remark'

You'd find that he was our best defender in the best defence in the league (imo)

Or you could say he is 4th choice english central defender alone, so how he makes top 10 of all english players is unknown to me.

woodgate king rio terry >> carragher and imo campbell and brown aswell.

Meh, LRD doesn't agree with me, but the experts who made up last seasons Premiership XI do. Carra is 4th choice because he is too similar to Terry

Crouching Tiger wrote:

l r d wrote:

Crouching Tiger wrote:

l r d wrote:

Crouching Tiger wrote:We've done best central midfield player, and best english central midfield player, but who is, overall, the best English player in the league?

My top 10:

1. Steven gerrard
2. Wayne Rooney
3. Joe Cole
4. Rio Ferdinand
5. John Terry
6. Ashely Cole
7. Frank Lampard
8. Micheal Carrick
9. Micheal Owen
10. Jamie Carragher

I'm Sure people will disagree with me!

carragher top 10

If you were to watch all our games from last season

*wait for some sort of 'I'd be very bored' remark'

You'd find that he was our best defender in the best defence in the league (imo)

Or you could say he is 4th choice english central defender alone, so how he makes top 10 of all english players is unknown to me.

woodgate king rio terry >> carragher and imo campbell and brown aswell.

Meh, LRD doesn't agree with me, but the experts who made up last seasons Premiership XI do. Carra is 4th choice because he is too similar to Terry

What is your list top 10 english players, or top 10 of who performed well last season?
he is 4th choice because woodgate was injured, he will soon be 5th choice or maybe 6th choice if brown is preferred

i will do top 5
rooney
gerrard
rio
cole
lampard

Rooney. Guys like Lampard and Gerrard despite winning trophies Rooney is still dreaming off shat their pants when they thought he wouldn't make the world cup, says it all...

Gerrard>Rooney>Cole

Gerrard.

1) Rooney
2) Gerrard
3) Scholes

-----------------------------------

4) Ferdinand
5) J Cole

Tweedledum wrote:Gerrard>Rooney>Cole

Gerrard
Scholes and Rooney for me


I may be new but I take it when I say Laampard is poor most people would agree?

yours truly wrote:

Tweedledum wrote:Gerrard>Rooney>Cole

Gerrard
Scholes and Rooney for me


I may be new but I take it when I say Laampard is poor most people would agree?

well I would, but he scores a lot of goals...

1 gerrard
2 terry
3 rio
4 rooney
5 j.cole
6 a.cole
7 crouch
8 johnson
9 parker
10 carrick

Yes, I think most are in agreement he should be dropped for Carrick. Gerrard, Carrick, Hargreaves, J Cole is the way forward.

Rio Ferdinand.

1 - R. Ferdinand
2 - Gerrard
3 - Rooney
4 - J.Cole
5 - King
6 - Scholes
7 - Carrick
8 - G. Neville
9 - Woodgate
10 - Ashton.

In reality: Routledge > All.

Agree totally Parky I'd like to see England adopt a 4-2-3-1 formation but obviously will never happen.

----------------Hargreaves---------Carrick-------------------


Gerrard------------------Rooney---------------J.Cole-----------------


-------------------------Ashton--------------------------

What you think I really don't rate Downing.

yours truly wrote:Agree totally Parky I'd like to see England adopt a 4-2-3-1 formation but obviously will never happen.

----------------Hargreaves---------Carrick-------------------


Gerrard------------------Rooney---------------J.Cole-----------------


-------------------------Ashton--------------------------

What you think I really don't rate Downing.

downing is pants

yours truly wrote:Agree totally Parky I'd like to see England adopt a 4-2-3-1 formation but obviously will never happen.

----------------Hargreaves---------Carrick-------------------


Gerrard------------------Rooney---------------J.Cole-----------------


-------------------------Ashton--------------------------

What you think I really don't rate Downing.

OBISPO!!! another 4-2-3-1 convert!

Nolan and Scholes

My top 10.

1. Jonathan Woodgate
2. Steven Gerrard
3. Wayne Rooney
4. Rio Ferdinand
5. Joe Cole
6. Ashley Cole
7. Ledley King
8. Paul Scholes
9. Frank Lampard
10. Scott Parker

I don't like Frank Lampard as a player(maybe he's just not my type) or as a person but the stats he produces are amazing, i find it hard to leave him out.

TeamSpirit wrote:

yours truly wrote:Agree totally Parky I'd like to see England adopt a 4-2-3-1 formation but obviously will never happen.

----------------Hargreaves---------Carrick-------------------


Gerrard------------------Rooney---------------J.Cole-----------------


-------------------------Ashton--------------------------

What you think I really don't rate Downing.

OBISPO!!! another 4-2-3-1 convert!

Totally agree LRD. 4-2-3-1 is the way forward true story!! I also don't rate any of England's 'elite' winger's. None of them have a footballing brain.

yours truly wrote:

TeamSpirit wrote:

yours truly wrote:Agree totally Parky I'd like to see England adopt a 4-2-3-1 formation but obviously will never happen.

----------------Hargreaves---------Carrick-------------------


Gerrard------------------Rooney---------------J.Cole-----------------


-------------------------Ashton--------------------------

What you think I really don't rate Downing.

OBISPO!!! another 4-2-3-1 convert!

Totally agree LRD. 4-2-3-1 is the way forward true story!! I also don't rate any of England's 'elite' winger's. None of them have a footballing brain.

no offence mate... but you are just blatantly copying what you have been reading for the past few months

COTR wrote:

yours truly wrote:

TeamSpirit wrote:

yours truly wrote:Agree totally Parky I'd like to see England adopt a 4-2-3-1 formation but obviously will never happen.

----------------Hargreaves---------Carrick-------------------


Gerrard------------------Rooney---------------J.Cole-----------------


-------------------------Ashton--------------------------

What you think I really don't rate Downing.

OBISPO!!! another 4-2-3-1 convert!

Totally agree LRD. 4-2-3-1 is the way forward true story!! I also don't rate any of England's 'elite' winger's. None of them have a footballing brain.

no offence mate... but you are just blatantly copying what you have been reading for the past few months

What makes you think that COTR? I only found this board 2 weeks ago. Am i getting on your bad side?

My top 10:

1.Stevie
2.Wayne
3.A cole
4.Lampard (despite the critics)
5.Scholes
6. J Cole
7.Ferdinanand
8.Carragher
9. Parker
10. Crouch

well (assuming you are telling the truth) your opinions are remarkably similar to quite a few posters on here... maybe just a coincidence but i prefer not to believe in coincidence's too much..

I do not have a bad side .... a suspicious side is another story though.. time will tell

luisgarciahedrinkssangria wrote:My top 10:

1.Stevie
2.Wayne
3.A cole
4.Lampard (despite the critics)
5.Scholes
6. J Cole
7.Ferdinanand
8.Carragher
9. Parker
10. Crouch

do u really think cashley is better than Joe cole?