Bayern and Makaay

as I have said many times, Bayern have to sell the Nederlander

a) the Spanish speaking faction will be weakened

b) Poldi will be able to play alongside somebody more team-oriented

c) Bayern need a FOOTBALLER as striker

HOWEVER

take a look at his stats

http://www.welt.de/sport/article940771/Fuer_Roy_Makaay_ist_bei_Bayern_kein_Platz_mehr.html

they ain't too shabby

apparently, Bayern would be willing to sell Makaay for 3 million Euro



top managers, them sausage manufacturers



what about Makaay going to Bremen

chrissi would cry tears of joy; finally, Werder would have their very own Dutchie

Poldi should complete a move to Carl Zeiss Jena...he won't be out of his depth this way

Bayern better hand over Podolski to us. It would be the best for everyone: Bayern don´t have to pay more than 10m, we have an acceptable replacement for Klose, and Löw and Germany will get an improved Prinz Poldi with a lot of match practice for the EC next year...

Agreed.

We'd make a top class striker out of him, like we did so often. The potential is there, but he will never live up to it below the Weißwurschtäquator.

Nope, Makaay will return to the real Heimat!!! So Werder, forget about an eventual swap! Just let Klose go!!!

...so Makaay can come to us.

Poldi will NEVER leave Bayern

it would be an admission of failure + all those young compatriotes are in Munich

Bremen making a move for Makaay would be REALISTIC though

he could play in the CL as well as the bundesliga; he's got a lot of experience as well

I would certainly not say NO

Hmm, if Bayern would offer 15m+Makaay for Klose we might think about it...

It's a disgrace how Makaay is treated by the Bayern board btw. A player they once bought for a record fee, who has scored a ton of goals for them in all these years. I wouldn't mind to see him in Bremen either, he'd still score a bagful for us, despite his age. In our attacking system, he'd get the service that was lacking at Bayern often.

And he is a great at penalties, something we really need.

Yeah, but I doubt he would come to Bremen. I´ve read he prefers Spain...

Spain? So far I've only read that some Dutch clubs are interested. But why shouldn't he want to join us? The perfect opportunity for payback!

Bayern sind nächste Saison zum Siegen verdammt. Und wir werden verdammt nochmal alles dafür tun, dass es schief geht. Versprochen.

Well, he has to decide whether to go to a title challenging and in-the-CL team, or a UEFA cup/midtable team in Spain, because I can't see the top clubs going in for him. Maybe a good Forlan replacement for Villarreal? (if Forlan signs for us)...or a Torres replacement for Atletico. Or Diego Milito out, Makaay in, at Zaragoza.

Let's see...

kas wrote:Well, he has to decide whether to go to a title challenging and in-the-CL team, or a UEFA cup/midtable team in Spain, because I can't see the top clubs going in for him. Maybe a good Forlan replacement for Villarreal? (if Forlan signs for us)...or a Torres replacement for Atletico. Or Diego Milito out, Makaay in, at Zaragoza.

Let's see...

Uno de los fichajes que cerrará el FC Barcelona la próxima temporada será el de un delantero. El club baraja ya varios nombres, entre ellos los de Makaay, Henry y Forlán, tres arietes que se ajustan al perfil que anda buscando la entidad desde la marcha del sueco Larsson la pasada campaña.
El adiós de Saviola y Ezquerro al final de este curso dejará la nómina de delanteros con pocos efectivos y, sabiéndolo, el club hace tiempo que está negociando para incorporar un ariete que ofrezca suficientes garantías en caso de volver a sufrir, como este año, el azote de las lesiones.

http://www.sport.es/default.asp?idpublicacio_PK=44&idioma=CAS&idnoticia_PK=410409&idseccio_PK=803

I´ve read Bayern would sell him for just about 3m Euro...looks like a good deal for such a stingy club like Barca...

Barça are a rich club, much richer than us, but much stingier than us also. Their founder was not from Switzerland, I have a feeling that he was Swabian actually.


Swabians are known for their stinginess over here..

blutgraetsche wrote:But why shouldn't he want to join us? The perfect opportunity for payback!

Bayern players are all brainwashed, they can be treated at will...

blutgraetsche wrote:Bayern sind nächste Saison zum Siegen verdammt. Und wir werden verdammt nochmal alles dafür tun, dass es schief geht. Versprochen.

Haha there definitely was a Makaay rumour recently, but I wouldn't be happy if it happened. If we're that desperate, I'd rather stick with Gudjohnsen and not loan Bojan Krkic.

kas wrote:Haha there definitely was a Makaay rumour recently, but I wouldn't be happy if it happened. If we're that desperate, I'd rather stick with Gudjohnsen and not loan Bojan Krkic.

What's wrong with such a profilic goalscorer. Although admittedly he hasn't got many years left but he could be a great mentor for Bojan and still would be a good back up for Eto'o.

Disgraceful how people and clubs treat Makaay!

I don't know what's supposed to be disgraceful

Bayern wanted to have Toni, which is jolly good

Bayern would be MAD not to go for Klose

Bayern already have Poldi

ie, Makaay, who happens to be bad for Poldi as well, is surplus to requirements

Bayern sind kein Altersheim

the one mistake Hoeness made though is to go public with Makaay's comment " IF Klose comes, I'm off"

that was private

by hinting that the price would be 3 million they effectively expressed their low regard for him as well

not Cricket either

I agree with DD. It's disgraceful.

I'd keep Makaay and get Klose for free next year.

The only reason why Makaay is (in your own words) 'bad' for Poldi, is becasue he's much better than him and more effective, therefore German football's own 'Knut die eisbaer' rightfully wouldn't get as much playing time.

The only way the 3th striker will see some playing time is if #1 isn't there anymore. Absolutely pitiful.

DD wrote:The only reason why Makaay is (in your own words) 'bad' for Poldi, is becasue he's much better than him and more effective, therefore German football's own 'Knut die eisbaer' rightfully wouldn't get as much playing time.

The only way the 3th striker will see some playing time is if #1 isn't there anymore. Absolutely pitiful.

I remember Makaay has put as a sub at Deportivo to make room for Tristan. And Makaay was the top scorer in Spain at that time.

DD

your tales from the animal kingdom are sweet

the truth is, "Makaay schneidet Poldi"

it's a disgrace and he MUST go

Effenberg wrote:I agree with DD. It's disgraceful.

I'd keep Makaay and get Klose for free next year.

I don't get it, he's always been treated like $h!t, while he's a model professional: doesn't throw fits, doesn't demand money, doesn't disrupt the club atmosphere, does what he's told, get on with his job (very well). And is very loyal.

Is this how people are meant to be treated? Perhaps he should have been a diva too then!

Bayern have no reason to get rid of Makaay, and certainly not a legitmate one to 'drop' him like yesterday's garbage.
He's a vital part of Bayern, has been instrumental over many years and including last year when other strikers were shooting blanks, and now he's about to forced out in such a manner, while there's nothing to guarentee that his successor will be as big a succes as he still is. ove reven neede. Let Klose come over for free next season.

Meanwhile... is Klose really worth €130.000+ a week?!!! Hell no! Chew on that.

If Poldi is so good, he has to show it - no matter who else is at the club.

Period.

gone wrote:

DD wrote:The only reason why Makaay is (in your own words) 'bad' for Poldi, is becasue he's much better than him and more effective, therefore German football's own 'Knut die eisbaer' rightfully wouldn't get as much playing time.

The only way the 3th striker will see some playing time is if #1 isn't there anymore. Absolutely pitiful.

I remember Makaay has put as a sub at Deportivo to make room for Tristan. And Makaay was the top scorer in Spain at that time.

And only a Golden boot winner.

Ottl, Look at his record!! Only the bomber has a better goal rating then Makaay

He did very well at Bayern, and Poldi had enough games to prove himself.

Remember the 4-0 against Ajax!!!

Effenberg wrote:If Poldi is so good, he has to show it - no matter who else is at the club.

Period.

Especially if there's a 'only' a striker in front of him which is so easily disposable.

Poldi cannot demand a #1 or even a #2 spot yet and Klose is not worth €130.000+ a week. Good business bayern and good luck in the future, trophyless and bankrupt.
Bad decision making by Bayern.

otto hat Euch alle lieb wrote:DD

your tales from the animal kingdom are sweet

the truth is, "Makaay schneidet Poldi"

it's a disgrace and he MUST go

Poldi = Knut


Makaay = Bokito


I know which one Bayern needs in a fight for the title. You're nothing more than one of those puppy cuddling, baby icebear loving beatnik. Get real and get a job Otto!
Poldi looks cute and German but he isn't going to win you anything for now.

DD wrote:

otto hat Euch alle lieb wrote:DD

your tales from the animal kingdom are sweet

the truth is, "Makaay schneidet Poldi"

it's a disgrace and he MUST go

Poldi = Knut


Makaay = Bokito


I know which one Bayern needs in a fight for the title. You're nothing more than one of those puppy cuddling, baby icebear loving beatnik. Get real and get a job Otto!
Poldi looks cute and German but he isn't going to win you anything for now.