Pierre's Dossier 2009/2010

Pierre Littbarski wrote:Nailed on pen by Vidic on Gomez at 0-0 - our impartial commentator from our state broadcaster said something along the lines of "I doubt he'll even embarrass himself to appeal for that"


We couldn't see the Vidic - Rodallega incident clearly.

I have great eyesight but couldn't see it clearly enough to say Vidic did wrong yet our impartial commentator from our state broadcaster could see it more than clearly enough to tell us that Vidic had done nothing wrong.

shazlx wrote:Eboue looked off-side in Arsenal's second goal. The movement was very fast, I would have liked to see MOTD do the last-man line by the idiots didn't...

It was 1-0 at that stage.

Pierre Littbarski wrote:Nailed on pen by Vidic on Gomez at 0-0.

Stimulus Package wrote:

Pierre Littbarski wrote:Nailed on pen by Vidic on Gomez at 0-0.

Would that be the same sort of penalty that you were objecting to Man U getting last season?


Curious...

Stimulus Package wrote:

Pierre Littbarski wrote:Nailed on pen by Vidic on Gomez at 0-0.

Would that be the same sort of penalty that you were objecting to Man U getting last season?


Curious...

Pierre Littbarski wrote:The Drogba goal is not what this dossier is really about though.

Its an honest mistake.

Glenn Johnnsonn wrote:Eduardo's dive tonight was disgusting and shameless, it also gives Vidic carte blanche to sodomise him relentlessly on Sunday while the referee turns a blind eye. I almost want it to happen.

L r dd wrote:Rooney's was a clear pen

L r dd wrote:
and they scored from the same move as the non penalty

Axeslammer wrote:

L r dd wrote:Rooney's was a clear pen

Nope : Rooney dived before the goalie touched him, the first foul is the one that counts.

Sheffield gunner wrote:As I said in the matchday topic, I think Rooney dived. His legs buckled before there was any contact. If Almunia had been able to keep out of his way he would have been down without any contact. As it is, Almunia clattered into him, and as far as I'm concerned it's a clear penalty. It was stupid, reckless goalkeeping and it got what it deserved.

I was surprised that Keys ventured away from his usual non-controversial position to raise this very point, even though he was ignored by the rest of the studio.

Glenn Johnnsonn wrote:
The referee couldn't not give it, but if Almunia manages to get out of they way Rooney has already started diving and you end up with a carbon copy of the Eduardo affair.

Axeslammer wrote:What a fucking disgrace that was

Fletcher torpedoes Arshavin and nothing is given, whilst Rooney gets a penalty for a dive