Would you like to react to this message? Create an account in a few clicks or log in to continue.

+31
Jaime
debaser
Sgoater1
Bashmachkin
The Easter Bunny
Di Caniooooo!
NeoChap
christmasborocooper
Pierre Littbarski
Kroos
Deluded F*ck™
Hlebagone
Super Progress
Fade out
shazlx
Rosicky
The Pröfessör
stinger
Chocolate Thunder
Matt_AFC
Romford Pele
Glenarch of the Glen
rosenthal
S4P
Cesc Soler
A & K
Chris 23*
Kimbo
Aristoskank
forza_rossi
Luis
35 posters

    Premier League Discussion Sat 4/Sun 5/Mon 6 December 2010

    Aristoskank
    Aristoskank


    Number of posts : 9733
    Registration date : 2008-09-19

    Premier League Discussion Sat 4/Sun 5/Mon 6 December 2010 - Page 8 Empty Re: Premier League Discussion Sat 4/Sun 5/Mon 6 December 2010

    Post by Aristoskank Tue Dec 07, 2010 7:02 pm

    Luis wrote:To suggest that the squad Rafa left behind is worse than the squad he inherited when he came here is ludicrous and there's absolutely no justification for it.

    Indeed, it is bullshit. But the germ of truth in that statement is that Benitez spent a lot of money and still left a team whose main players are either ageing or crocked, with no proper backup striker when your main striker is injury prone, with no wingers worth mentioning despite several big(ish) money signings, and with a second rate central midfield at best.

    I wont go in to it again but all I'll say is when Houllier left, if we had opted then for Hodgson or someone like him instead of Benitez we would be lightyears behind where are now in terms of quality players.

    Really? Quality players like Babel? Robbie Keane? Peter Crouch? Mark Gonzalez? Glen Johnson? Skrtel? Josemi?

    Aside from Torres, who cost a bundle and is an inconsistent crock, who is it that Benitez signed who you couldn't have got otherwise? Alonso and Mascherano, OK, but they were both gone as soon as a big Spanish club showed an interest.

    We're still lacking as a squad and we need 2 or three big money signings to see us challenge for the top 4 properly but with the right management we shouldn't be too far behind who ever will finish 4th this season be it Spurs or City and that's down to Rafa changing us from a team about to slip into mid-table medriocrity into a European force with quality in all departments.

    When Benitez took over you'd just finished a reasonably comfortable fourth. The following season you finished 5th, with less points and less goals scored. Last season you finished 7th. This season you're in mid-table mediocrity.

    Believe what you like about Rafa, but what you are saying simply isn't true.
    christmasborocooper
    christmasborocooper


    Number of posts : 39348
    Age : 36
    Registration date : 2006-08-06

    Premier League Discussion Sat 4/Sun 5/Mon 6 December 2010 - Page 8 Empty Re: Premier League Discussion Sat 4/Sun 5/Mon 6 December 2010

    Post by christmasborocooper Tue Dec 07, 2010 7:45 pm

    Techincally, he's saying Houllier left a good squad for Rafa..so he's not that xenophobic.
    Aristoskank
    Aristoskank


    Number of posts : 9733
    Registration date : 2008-09-19

    Premier League Discussion Sat 4/Sun 5/Mon 6 December 2010 - Page 8 Empty Re: Premier League Discussion Sat 4/Sun 5/Mon 6 December 2010

    Post by Aristoskank Tue Dec 07, 2010 7:57 pm

    borocooper wrote:Techincally, he's saying Houllier left a good squad for Rafa..so he's not that xenophobic.

    Damn straight. Ale
    Six
    Six


    Number of posts : 4390
    Supports : Liverpool
    Registration date : 2009-01-14

    Premier League Discussion Sat 4/Sun 5/Mon 6 December 2010 - Page 8 Empty Re: Premier League Discussion Sat 4/Sun 5/Mon 6 December 2010

    Post by Six Tue Dec 07, 2010 8:42 pm

    Roy has recently changed his tune somewhat about the quality of our squad, saying we have some quality youngsters like Wilson, Pacheco and Kelly (Rafa didn't inherit any young players worthy of a mention). So even Roy might disagree!

    When people talk about the squad Rafa left behind they always forget to mention how he was unable to spend money in his last 3 transfer windows. Really it's the Squad G & H (and Rafa, and Ricky Parry etc.) left behind, but everyone seems to have forgotten about them already.

    Sponsored content


    Premier League Discussion Sat 4/Sun 5/Mon 6 December 2010 - Page 8 Empty Re: Premier League Discussion Sat 4/Sun 5/Mon 6 December 2010

    Post by Sponsored content


      Current date/time is Mon May 20, 2024 2:33 am