by The Easter Bunny Mon Jun 18, 2012 1:27 am
Disco Benny wrote:This thread has gone batshit mental
Mikel played as an AM when he was younger, but he never developed (some say he was a lazy trainer) he would not be able to play as a CM or AM in the Premiership but his current DM role suits him.
Cabaye as good as Modric
We'll see how well he performs next season, Modric plays in a better team so he will obviously look like the better player but Cabaye outshone him this season, and was easily one of the most instrumental players in the Prem last season. However the dreaded SSS and the lack of proper rest might affect his ability to play as many games at such a high intensity for Newcastle which will obviously attribute to a drop in form. Also if Tiote goes and Newcastle fail to sign a similar player who can cover as much ground and pass as accurately then Cabaye again will suffer as he will have to work harder off the ball.
Joe Cole
While he was a very good player, he was not 'great' otherwise Mourinho would have built Chelsea around him instead of reshaping him into what he is now. I remember going to watch West Ham with one of my friends family when I was younger and Cole was just the biggest crowd pleaser, when I was younger I thought he was the best player as he would easily go past 2-3 players with ease but then would not play the final pass, but typical english mentality wow he beat 3 players and the whole crowd applaud. Now when I look back to it, he had the technical ability but obviously lacks certain mental attributes which might have manifested at Chelsea and might be a reason for his sharp decline. Also if you look at Cole's stats they are not that impressive considering the ability he had/has, hopefully Rodgers gives him a chance and he can play well with a proactive footballing manager.
Ribery- Is Ribery overrated? This depends on when the question is asked, the media hype Ribery up to the levels of Ronaldo and Messi, but he simply is not at the level. He is a very good player and I think his ability to hold onto the ball(under pressure) and create are his greatest strengths. Since Bayern have goal scorers like Gomez and Robben I think people expect Ribery to score an equal amount, but usually the creators are put behind the goal scorers by the media and fans. I believe Ribery has over 50 odd assists in the last 2 seasons, a truly incredible amount. But apart from the Champions League the only other time a lot of people see him play is during the International season where Ribery has been quite poor, 60 games 10 goals and 10 assists? Something along those lines, if he reciprocated his club form for his country in the form of assists I believe more people would stop saying he is overrated.
Samaras is a donkey, while I haven't watched Celtic play for a few months whenever I watched him play he wasn't that impressive. If you can't dominate in the SPL well, it tells you about the quality of the player look at Kris Boyd ffs. Samaras has a good touch, but if he was such a great player he would not of failed in the Premiership and would be dominating the SPL in terms of assists, pass competition etc